Climate science has been clear for decades: Since at least the 1950s, oil and gas companies have known that their fossil fuels release planet-warming carbon dioxide emissions into the atmosphere.
And we’ve known that those emissions cause dangerous planetary impacts like the melting of our ice caps, rising sea levels, and “potentially serious environmental damage worldwide,” as one 1968 study put it.
In the years since, experts learned even more about how climate change fuels extreme weather like storms, droughts, and heat waves.
Actually nailing down the direct link between one company’s emissions and the amount of warming the Earth has experienced, though, or how much climate change amped up the intensity of a particular storm, has been a more complicated calculus.
The effort to answer those questions is called attribution science. Though a more recent field than the extensive research on the harms of fossil fuels, it’s a burgeoning area of study that has seen significant scientific advancements over the past two decades.
And it’s an increasingly important field for those looking to hold fossil fuel companies accountable for climate damages.
This kind of research is essential to climate litigation, and even plays a part in the major climate case Suncor v. Boulder, for which the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments this week.
That Big Oil is fighting it, experts say, is another example of their history of climate denial.
The origins of attribution science
While research on the climate impact of burning fossil fuels began as early as the 1950s, the idea of “attribution,” or establishing a cause-and-effect connection, didn’t come until decades later.
The Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change’s (IPCC) third report, published in 2001, noted that “Detection and attribution studies consistently find evidence for an anthropogenic signal in the climate record of the last 35 to 50 years.”
In other words: We could say, scientifically, that human activity played a role in changing the climate.
But the field was still nascent. In 2003, though, a commentary published in Nature asked a crucial question: “Will it ever be possible to sue anyone for damaging the climate?”
Written by University of Oxford physicist and climate scientist Myles Allen, the piece kicked off the effort to connect climate change to specific events—in his case, a flood that brought the waters of the River Thames “about 30 centimetres from my kitchen door”—as well as who could be responsible for paying for those damages.
The scientific models to make those connections didn’t even exist yet.
“We are not yet in the position to produce such figures for the contribution of greenhouse-gas emissions to the increased risk of flooding in south Oxford,” he wrote. “But the point is, if we get the science right, we could be.”
By the next year, he had found a way.
In 2004, Allen and two other climate scientists published a study in Nature that estimated the role that human influence played in increasing the risk of a deadly European heat wave, widely considered the first extreme weather attribution study.
Different types of attribution science
That heat wave study is an example of a specific subset of attribution science called event attribution. It’s one of multiple subsets of the field.
Event attribution focuses on figuring out climate change’s role in specific instances of extreme weather, like that 2003 heat wave, or, say, Hurricane Katrina.
When Katrina occurred in 2005, attribution science wasn’t as advanced, but it has expanded significantly in the years since.
Two decades later, using more advanced attribution analysis, Climate Central looked back at Katrina to analyze climate change’s “fingerprint” on the event. It found that “climate change made [Katrina’s] ocean temperatures up to 18 times more likely and, along with tropical climate warming, increased Katrina’s maximum sustained wind speed by 5 mph.”
And since the Earth has warmed even more since then, the outlet added that today’s climate could have made for an even stronger storm.
Separate from event attribution is trend attribution, which focuses more broadly on identifying the human impact on long-term climate trends, rather than specific events.
That subset looks at human-caused climate change’s role—or the “human fingerprint”—on overall global warming, ocean warming, sea levels, and so on. This field was the focus of the 1990s research, like what was mentioned in that IPCC report.
Another subset emerged in 2014, called source attribution, when scientist Richard Heede, who founded and leads the Climate Accountability Institute, released his landmark Carbon Majors report. The aim of that work, Heede says, “was to see if we can quantify emissions attributable to one company over its entire history.”
Heede figured out exactly how many fossil fuel emissions major oil, coal, gas, and cement companies produced over their lifetime, then assigned those companies a share of total greenhouse gas pollution.
Of all the global emissions produced between 1751 and 2010, for example, Chevron was responsible for 3.52%, that report found.
There’s also a more recent subset of the field called impact attribution—or damage attribution—which looks not just at the intensity of specific extreme weather, but the social and economic consequences of climate change’s extreme impacts. That research has linked human-caused climate change to more deaths from extreme heat, for example.
Source attribution and climate litigation
Source attribution science plays a major role in climate litigation, or the lawsuits that seek to hold fossil fuel companies accountable for their role in climate change and the damage it has caused.
To Heede, this kind of science was a necessary departure from the typical ways of looking at climate responsibility.
“It’s not based on the conventional model of attributing responsibility to nations,” he says. Much of modern climate policy focuses on what countries should do to reduce emissions or which nations should pay for climate mitigation.
Instead, Heede’s work shifted that focus to the corporations that, he says, “have known about the hazards of their products, and the carbon in their products, to global atmospheric instability.”
It’s not only companies to blame for climate change, he adds; governments are also responsible, and individual consumers even play a role. But companies have a “substantial responsibility because they have known the science for decades,” he says.
“They then had a choice of going public with it, engaging with the public and governments to further study climate change to ascertain what could be done to reduce emissions,” he says, “and instead, most oil and gas companies invested in climate obfuscation and denial in order to delay action.”
The Suncor v. Boulder Supreme Court Case
Now, communities and municipalities are trying to hold those specific companies accountable by using the science that links their emissions to climate harms. But fossil fuel companies are continuing their trend of denial.
There are some two dozen lawsuits pending in the United States, mostly brought by states or cities as well as tribes, looking to get monetary damages from fossil fuel companies for their role in climate change, according to Columbia Law School.
This week, the Supreme Court heard arguments in one of those cases, called Suncor Energy Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County.
That case was originally filed in 2018, when the city and county of Boulder, Colorado, sued Exxon and Suncor “for the substantial role they played and continue to play in causing, contributing to and exacerbating climate change.”
“Plaintiffs and their taxpayers cannot pay the full costs of all that is needed, nor should they,” the lawsuit read. “The costs should be shared by the Suncor and Exxon Defendants because they knowingly and substantially contributed to the climate crisis.”
The oil companies argued that the case should be heard in federal court rather than state court. Now, the Supreme Court will decide whether that state case can continue—and the decision could affect the future of climate litigation.
Those companies have also attacked the attribution science at the core of that case, arguing in a brief that greenhouse gas emissions “cannot be unmixed and traced to their sources in particular States or countries.”
In response, the Natural Resources Defense Council filed a supporting brief, Bloomberg Law reported, saying that these companies “overlook an extensive body of established climate science that draws these causal lines.”
Fossil fuel companies have also long opposed taking responsibility for Scope 3 emissions, or the emissions that come from the downstream use of their products, like the pollution from a car that runs on gasoline. Scope 3 emissions can account for 80-to-95% of a Big Oil company’s carbon footprint.
“They feel the consumer is solely responsible for the use of their products,” Heede says. “My opinion is different, that companies have a substantial burden of responsibility for the products they sell to consumers.”
If the Supreme Court halts the state-level case against Suncor, it could “kill many, if not all,” of the currently pending climate lawsuits that look to hold the fossil fuel industry accountable for climate change, Jeff Goodell, author of The Heat Will Kill You First: Life and Death on a Scorched Planet, wrote in the New York Times.
That seems to be what Big Oil and its enablers are hoping for.
In a brief supporting the industry filed by lawyers for the Trump administration, they noted that if the case can proceed under state law, then “every locality in the country could sue essentially anyone in the world for contributing to global climate change.”
Even some justices are concerned about that potential.
“Presumably if you prevail, the next day, a municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit that will probably copy your pleadings,” said Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., per the New York Times. “How would you think that will work out on the ground?”
These arguments are “part of a coordinated, well-resourced push to shut down fossil fuel accountability efforts across the country,” Kathy Mulvey, Fossil Fuel Accountability program director at the Union of Concerned Scientists, said in a statement.
But even if that happens, it won’t stop this quest for accountability, or the work being done on attribution science, experts say.
“Science is not going to be stopped,” Heede says. “We will have increasingly more sophisticated studies looking at different kinds of climate events . . . and that will just expand as climate impacts grow in severity, and attribute them not only to fossil fuels overall, but to specific companies.”
Attribution science will only continue to improve, both in terms of accuracy and comprehensiveness, he adds.
And even if Boulder loses in this case, Heede says, he doesn’t think that will “shut down municipalities’ incentive to file suit against companies that have acted irresponsibly in terms of not cleaning up the mess they have created.”