Skip to main content

Fast Company

This is the one role founders should absolutely outsource

1 month ago

In a startup’s earliest days, founders are the only salespeople by default. And founders who don’t have any previous sales experience are often surprised to find that they’re very effective at it. But this makes sense; after all, they’re the one who first saw the need for the product and drove its creation.

A few years ago, I received a call from the CEO of a nascent but fast-growing and well-respected enterprise software startup. He had a problem. His company had expanded to a 20-person sales force with a VP of sales at the helm, yet the sales team still needed his help to close most large deals and had missed their revenue targets for two consecutive quarters. He simply couldn’t continue to be the backstop for all the company’s salespeople.

I began working with the CEO to figure out why his sales team couldn’t reproduce his success. I started by asking his VP of sales a simple question: “Do you use a sales playbook?” The VP’s response was alarming. Not only did his team not use a playbook, he wasn’t even aware the team needed one.

Beyond a certain point, you can’t rely on intuition to drive sales. You need formal, repeatable processes that transform sales into a disciplined function rather than an improvised and inconsistent art form.

Replicate yourself

The playbook is a step-by-step description of the practices and behaviors you’ve found will lead to a successful sale. It’s how you teach your sales team what has worked for you, the founder and first salesperson, so it becomes second nature to them.

Over the course of a few weeks, this CEO and I prepared for and debriefed after customer meetings to figure out his recipe for closing deals. Once we’d done this, we analyzed the key phrases the CEO used to describe the product and its value, then translated them into a set of narratives for the sales team to use on customer calls. In a matter of weeks, they started closing more deals without the CEO’s help.

The key message for startup founders at this stage is: Replicate yourself. The best way to do this is to analyze and document the winning strategies and tactics that have enabled you to sell successfully in the early days.

Avoid at all costs reaching a point where you have a team of 10 or 20 salespeople all doing their own thing, forcing every new sales hire to reinvent how to sell.

If new salespeople are successful and making quota, you know your repeatable sales motion and playbook are working. If they aren’t, then you need to return to refining your playbook before hiring more salespeople. I can’t stress this enough: If your salespeople aren’t consistently making quota using your expanded playbook, you have more work to do, and you’re not ready to go for growth and add additional—and expensive—salespeople to your payroll.

Step on the gas

Only once you’ve proven you can bring new salespeople on board, teach them the playbook, and have them reliably hit quota should you begin scaling and hire more than eight to 10 salespeople. The scaling phase is the time to step on the gas and accelerate growth. If revenue grows as expected, the sales organization could be 50 or 100 people strong within a couple of years.

Upgrade your executive team

As the demands on you and the business increase, not everyone will successfully scale in their role. An $80 million company must be run differently from a $20 million company. The team you need now might be very different from the one you had in the early days.

This is often a moment when you have no choice but to significantly upgrade your go-to-market leadership, which can be a brutal process. Not only do you have to recruit senior talent that complements the leaders and team you already have—including your initial trailblazer hires, who are often more junior than what you’ll need at this stage—you might even have to make tough decisions to let go of people who have been with you since the earliest days.

If your VP of sales is barely holding it together with a team of 10, imagine them with a team of 50 or 100. If that thought makes you nervous, you’ll know you have to bring in a chief revenue officer (CRO) above them sooner rather than later, or maybe even replace them.

Layer in a sales management team

You’ll also layer in a sales management team reporting to the VP of sales or CRO, who will run and scale increasingly specialized sales teams. You’ll need two types of leaders as you grow: Those who report directly to you, and those who report to your executive team, sometimes called the middle management layer.

As you accelerate, you’ll hire one manager for roughly every eight salespeople. The sales team managers you hire will now take over the day-to-day operations, performance, and culture of their teams.

Form specialized sales teams

Once you grow past 10 or 15 salespeople, you’ll likely find it necessary to specialize your sales team. Until now, you might have loosely segmented salespeople by use case, customer size, or geography. If so, now is the time to formalize this specialization to make the team more efficient. For example, you might have a small and medium business (SMB) team, a midmarket team, and an inside enterprise team.

Hire or promote high-performing sales leaders for each of these teams with experience in that specialization. With these hires also comes an important change to your pipeline cadence. Each team will conduct their own pipeline meeting, run by the specialized team leader. The VP of sales will then conduct pipeline meetings with only these team leads, who will be their direct reports.

Give sales more space, but stay on top of your metrics

One of the challenges you’ll face as the company grows is to give direct reports like the VP of sales more room to maneuver without your becoming disengaged from the function. When scaling up, you’ll want to give your now-proven VP of sales the space to lead their organization and keep their teams motivated. But at the same time, you want to keep an eye on team performance. You should never be surprised if your sales leader suddenly doesn’t make their number, or learn about the sales team’s struggles only close to quarter end when it’s too late to take action.

I have talked about how you need to replicate yourself and teach new salespeople to use the key phrases and tactics that have worked for you. That replication will be harder to achieve with such a big team, and new salespeople probably won’t mimic you as easily and as much as the early team did. That is just part of growing a business.

Even if your company is tiny, you need to be preparing for a time when it won’t be. The best way to do that is to move at the right time beyond the intuition and improvisation of the early days toward analysis, intentionality, and a structured and systematic approach to building out your go-to-market. Now go off and build. Your company, and your team, need you.


Adapted from Built to Grow: A Handbook for High-Performance Sales Teams by Stephanie Friedman, published on October 13, 2026 by Stripe Press.

Apple’s HomeView is nearly a decade late. That might not matter

1 month ago

Apple thinks you might want a screen in your kitchen or bedroom. It’s nearly a decade late to the party, with its $299 HomeView, announced on October 13, arriving nine years after Amazon unveiled the Echo Show, and eight after Google came out with its own Home Hub.

But that tardiness doesn’t matter for the Cupertino tech giant, which has made its name by arriving with technology others have already developed, then doing it better—and making it a more enviable object to own. It’s a playbook Apple has honed, one that bets big on its design chops to differentiate its products from what’s already on the market. And once again, it might prove successful with the HomeView.

When Apple released the iPod, it was far from the first MP3 player on the market. When the iPhone debuted in 2007, it was just one of many smartphones available to buy. What both did, though, was redefine the market by offering something distinctly Apple: beautiful engineering and clever design that made them, rather than their competitors, synonymous with their respective categories. The same is arguably true of the Apple Watch and AirPods, both of which hold outsized positions in their markets.

[Photo: Apple]

On the face of it, HomeView follows the same formula. Its seven-inch screen sits on a tilting aluminum stand and adjusts its display depending on how close a user is. Using facial recognition, it can present tailored information to up to six household members. That’s not unique: Google’s Nest Hub Max has long offered facial recognition to personalize calendars and other information, while Amazon’s Echo Show can recognize individual users and adjust what’s displayed depending on how far away they are. But everything from the color-matched cables to the pared-back design is the sort of thing that leaves Apple fans in raptures.

Elsewhere, the HomeView isn’t great shakes. Amazon’s Echo Show can use its built-in camera for remote home monitoring, letting you check on your house while you’re away, a feature HomeView doesn’t offer. The same is true in the bedroom: Google’s second-generation Nest Hub can use radar to monitor your sleep without needing a wearable device, something Apple doesn’t offer. The price tag is also higher than those of similarly equipped products already on the market.

And yet HomeView could sell in droves, even if analysts forecast a broader dip in smart display shipments this year. That’s because Apple has made it its business not to be first in the race, but to understand what we want to buy and offer the idealized version of it.

I let an AI assistant shop for me and the reviewers got nothing

1 month ago

There’s a new kind of AI in town, and it’s all about you. Which is to say you, personally—these are the new personal AI assistants that go by names like Muse, Dots, and Grok Bot, and they’re ready to dismantle much of the friction in your life. Need to research a trip, book a restaurant, or choose between healthcare plans? With the right context, they can handle it all for you, complete with a smile on their mascot-like avatars.

But just how does one of these assistants recommend what to buy? To find out, I asked my Muse, who I named Jones, which robot vacuum to buy. (Muse is made by Meta, which debuted it on Sept. 8) Jones responded with a surprisingly small number of recommendations—just a couple of models—with links to go make the purchase. Each of those links provided options to go to a retailer website or buy the vacuum right there in the app.

When I pressed Jones on why it had chosen those particular models, and whether it had looked at review sites specifically, it fessed up that it had looked at both retail sites and review roundups. On the latter, it leaned heavily on a site called Vacuum Wars, which does extensive hands-on testing of this category, and Jones seemed to understand that made it more authoritative. Of the other “review sites” it cited, one was a thin repackaging of Vacuum Wars data, and another was an AI-generated roundup on an aromatherapy blog. Vacuum Wars, I should point out, makes most of its money from the affiliate revenue it gets when its readers transact.

{"blockType":"mv-promo-block","data":{"imageDesktopUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/media-copilot.png","imageMobileUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/fe289316-bc4f-44ef-96bf-148b3d8578c1_1440x1440.png","eyebrow":"","headline":"\u003Cstrong\u003ESubscribe to The Media Copilot\u003C\/strong\u003E","dek":"Want more about how AI is changing media? Never miss an update from Pete Pachal by signing up for The Media Copilot. To learn more visit \u003Ca href=\u0022https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/\u0022\u003Emediacopilot.substack.com\u003C\/a\u003E","subhed":"","description":"","ctaText":"SIGN UP","ctaUrl":"https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/","theme":{"bg":"#f5f5f5","text":"#000000","eyebrow":"#9aa2aa","subhed":"#ffffff","buttonBg":"#000000","buttonHoverBg":"#3b3f46","buttonText":"#ffffff"},"imageDesktopId":91453847,"imageMobileId":91453848,"shareable":false,"slug":"","wpCssClasses":""}}

At this point I should caveat that my example is one test done in one AI app. These personal assistants are brand new, and the AI information economy is still developing. Nothing definitive should be gleaned from this experience. Nonetheless, I think what I discovered is instructive since it shows the vast distance between how product recommendations work in AI vs. the open web, and what that gap means for publishers whose business depends on them.

I think this is worth talking about, now, because I wholeheartedly believe these new apps—or some version of them—will be a success. The idea of the single, all-knowing AI with a simple “talk to me” interface has been the dream since at least the original Star Trek, where the Enterprise computer would somehow magically always know the right context to give the best and most precise answer. The AI platforms have been heading this way, with Anthropic discarding the Chat/Cowork toggle, and OpenAI’s move to sunset custom GPTs being the latest indicators. Everything is pointed toward a singular AI experience.

Who got left out of the answer

Back to buying my robot vacuum: Muse looking to Vacuum Wars as the most definitive review site is probably appropriate, but it also wasn’t a fair fight. Absent from its considerations were Wirecutter, PCMag, and Consumer Reports, all major review sites that have published roundups of robot vacuums. There are plausible reasons for this: Wirecutter is a New York Times property, PCMag is owned by Ziff Davis, and both are hostile to AI companies substituting their content with AI answers. The Times blocks AI crawlers across the board, and Ziff Davis is suing OpenAI. Consumer Reports is likewise defensive about its content, keeping its full ratings behind a membership. But that’s my inference. Jones never said it was blocked from anything.

I should pause for another caveat: What Jones told me it did and what it actually did aren’t necessarily the same thing. It’s possible other sites were in the mix and it never told me, or there may be guardrails in place that it’s not even aware of. So grains of generative salt all around.

Potentially even more revealing were the retail sites that Jones directed me to: Best Buy, Target, and manufacturer retail sites like Dreame. Not present at all: Amazon. That’s because, shortly after Muse made its debut, Amazon blocked the service from transacting on its site. I should note here that Mark Zuckerberg, speaking at Meta Connect on Sept. 23, said transactions in Muse would be a source of revenue, meaning Meta would take a cut of any purchases in the app. 

After checking out multiple links that Jones showed me, I saw no tracking specific to the app, though one did carry the manufacturer’s own Facebook campaign tag. Those were links out to retailer sites, and any fee would presumably be collected on purchases made inside the app, out of view. Either they’re tracking purchases in some invisible way, or Meta’s not getting paid yet.

Someone else not getting paid: Vacuum Wars. As I mentioned, transactional links are how the site makes money, and almost all of them link to Amazon, which, again, is a non-presence in Muse. To recap, Vacuum Wars funds its research via Amazon links, Muse takes that research to make recommendations, and then points users to other retailers. Vacuum Wars says affiliate links are its primary source of income, and that it takes no sponsorships or free products from manufacturers.

It’s worse than we thought

All this adds up to an even murkier future for sites that make their dollar on product recommendations. If these personal assistants take off—and I believe they will—the product advice they give will depend on a host of factors, and potentially be balkanized to the point where the path from a published review to an AI recommendation will be more like a labyrinth than a straight line.

Assistants will only direct users to retailers they have access to. For Muse, that’s Shopify, Walmart, and Best Buy, but no Amazon. Amazon blocks nearly every outside assistant, not just Muse, while running its own. Amazon’s Alexa for Shopping carries sponsored prompts in its answers, and its Buy for Me feature checks out on other brands’ sites. OpenAI pulled ChatGPT’s built-in checkout in March and now hands shoppers off to merchants’ own sites and apps. If a review site hopes to get a commission, it would theoretically need a deal for every assistant-and-store pair. The open web needed one link.

The product that your assistant recommends might end up bending to that access. In my case, the products that Jones pointed me towards actually ended up being different from the ones on Vacuum Wars’ definitive list, recommending the Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2 instead of the Dreame L60 Ultra PE, the model its own summary of the reviews had singled out. It’s unclear why it did that, but everything it recommended had an active checkout page. It’s fair to say the assistant can only recommend what it can sell, so there’s a path for commercial considerations to get in without anyone buying an ad.

With Amazon drawing battle lines, review publishers will have some hard choices to make as these assistants become more popular. Blocking won’t help, as the repackaged Vacuum Wars content reveals: you might block, but reviewclonecashgrab.slop certainly won’t. Your well-researched content could end up driving sales at other retailers. On top of that, Amazon has cut commissions by as much as 50% for some publishers. Amazon is still most people’s first stop to buy online, but its defensive move against Muse shows it’s feeling vulnerable. That leaves reviewers two imperfect options: strike affiliate deals with the stores assistants can reach, or stop chasing the commission and sell the test data itself to the AI companies.

The rules are still being written

Remember: This is one category, and one assistant. And while it’s still early days for AI, it’s basically day one for these new personal everything buddies. Standards for transacting and commissions from AI-based transactions are still emerging, and the Universal Commerce Protocol (Amazon joined its governing body in April) may eventually produce a framework that takes into account all the players, including publishers.

But make no mistake: there’s still a lot to hammer out. As AI assistants take on a more central role in our lives, they’ll begin to abstract away the customer journey—comparing different products or services, filtering them by what’s important to you, and getting the best price. There’s money to be made at every stage, and the irony of the AI era is that we’re starting from a point where the parties tasked with doing the unbiased and thorough research are the ones who are the most shut out.

{"blockType":"mv-promo-block","data":{"imageDesktopUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/media-copilot.png","imageMobileUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2025\/03\/fe289316-bc4f-44ef-96bf-148b3d8578c1_1440x1440.png","eyebrow":"","headline":"\u003Cstrong\u003ESubscribe to The Media Copilot\u003C\/strong\u003E","dek":"Want more about how AI is changing media? Never miss an update from Pete Pachal by signing up for The Media Copilot. To learn more visit \u003Ca href=\u0022https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/\u0022\u003Emediacopilot.substack.com\u003C\/a\u003E","subhed":"","description":"","ctaText":"SIGN UP","ctaUrl":"https:\/\/mediacopilot.substack.com\/","theme":{"bg":"#f5f5f5","text":"#000000","eyebrow":"#9aa2aa","subhed":"#ffffff","buttonBg":"#000000","buttonHoverBg":"#3b3f46","buttonText":"#ffffff"},"imageDesktopId":91453847,"imageMobileId":91453848,"shareable":false,"slug":"","wpCssClasses":""}}

Getty Images was worth $4.8 billion just 4 years ago. Now it’s filing for bankruptcy

1 month ago

Getty Images is filing for bankruptcy and plans to go private, the company announced on Monday.A release says that the company plans to begin the process of filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the weeks ahead and undergo massive restructuring, which will ultimately see complete control and ownership of the company in the hands of the Getty family, as well as Koch Equity Development.

As a part of the restructuring, Koch Equity Development (which is the investment arm of Koch, Inc.) will invest up to $533 million, and as the process progresses, the company will “continue to operate in the normal course,” and “vendors will be unaffected and paid in full in the ordinary course of business,” according to the company’s release.

Getty is perhaps best known as a source of photographs and stock images used for a variety of purposes, and has faced significant headwinds with the advent of AI-generated imagery in recent years. Notably, in a recent investor presentation, company materials noted that there was “declining agency demand and disruption to the iStock eCommerce business. It had also announced plans to merge with Shutterstock in January—a plan that has since been scrapped.

Even so, company leadership says that it’s confident that going private and restructuring will help it regain its footing.

Mark Getty, Getty Images’ co-founder and chairman of the board, said in the company release that he was “pleased to continue our strong partnership with Koch Equity Development and the lender groups to provide capital structure improvements that will enable us to build on our solid foundation and seize new growth opportunities.”

Additionally, Mike Harris, senior managing director and co-head at Koch Equity Development, said that the group remains “confident in the company’s future and fully support this transaction alongside the Getty family. This equity investment will provide Getty Images with a firm financial foundation and greater flexibility to continue investing in its employees, customers, contributors, and future growth.”

Kroger layoffs: Grocery giant will slash thousands of corporate jobs as CEO asserts need for ‘faster decisions’

1 month ago

Kroger Co. plans to cut more than a third of its corporate workforce in the next three years under new CEO Greg Foran, according to an internal memo obtained by Fast Company. Foran joined the grocery giant in February to succeed interim CEO Ron Sargent.

The Cincinnati company’s corporate workforce is around 8,200 people, which means nearly 3,000 roles will be cut. The layoffs will only impact corporate roles, not store or distribution jobs. 

“Simplifying means making faster decisions and deploying more resources where they matter most,” Foran wrote in the memo. “Our company has more layers, more handoffs and more overhead than we need.” 

“We have the opportunity to make changes that will create broader roles and faster decision making,” Foran wrote. “This lets us move vital resources closer to the customer to lower prices, invest in our associates and create a better shopping experience.”

Foran also said in the memo that the company “must adapt and take advantage of technology.”

Grocery costs have soared

While the memo does not specify artificial intelligence as the technology, Kroger published an AI strategy plan in September, saying it will start using AI models to manage workflows and customer data, and kick off an AI literacy training program for employees. 

Foran has pushed to implement price cuts across Kroger products as the company, which also operates the Fred Meyer and Ralphs grocery store chains, has been trying to compete with Walmart and Costco prices.

Not the first mass layoffs at Kroger

Last year, Kroger announced it was cutting nearly 1,000 jobs from its corporate workforce, Fast Company previously reported.

Interim CEO Ron Sargent said that the savings would be reinvested in the company to help open new locations, offer more store-level jobs, and contribute to product price reductions.

Kroger has not said whether the cuts are related to its legal dispute with Albertsons. It faces a claim of more than $9 billion from Albertsons over the collapse of its merger, which was blocked on antitrust grounds in December 2024, Bloomberg reported.

The grocery chain has also been shuttering locations since June 2025, after it announced a footprint optimization plan that would result in 60 stores being closed.

A livestreamed public execution would be psychologically damaging to kids. Experts weigh in on what parents can do

1 month ago

This is not an article about politics, capital punishment, or whether the Fort Hood shooter deserves to be executed in public for his crimes.

Instead, it’s focused on the unprecedented parental challenge of handling the near-certain prospect that children will hear of or see footage of the Dec. 3 U.S. execution by firing squad of Nidal Malik Hasan if the Trump administration follows through with plans to livestream the event.

The danger stretches beyond the broadcast itself, because history shows graphic video from the event could be clipped, copied, and pushed into children’s social feeds even if the original stream is restricted.

Experts suggest that grownups who care about children start by setting aside matters of politics and public policy, like the November 3 U.S. midterm elections and the debate over capital punishment. Focus instead on how witnessing someone’s death by firing squad might land with young viewers—and how best to reassure and protect them.

Here are some guidelines that might help.

Keep empathy for kids in mind—and facts at hand

Mis- and disinformation reach children, too. It’s important for parents to have credibility with them, especially because their real, unspoken question might be: Are we safe? Have in hand some basic facts about the case and state them gently.

“It will be easier to have a position, share your family’s values, and discuss things with a potentially overwhelmed child once you’ve taken the time to gather accurate, up-to-date info and assess your child’s needs,” according to Common Sense Media, which advises parents on entertainment and technology.

Trump approved Hasan’s execution by firing squad December 3 at Fort Hood. A few days later, the Pentagon announced the event would be livestreamed.

“People need to understand that there’s serious consequences for these types of things,” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth told Real America’s Voice, a conservative outlet.

Hasan, an Army psychiatrist, was convicted of killing 13 people there in 2009 when he walked into a medical building where soldiers were getting checkups and opened fire with a laser-sighted handgun. He said it was an effort to stop them from going to Afghanistan and killing his fellow Muslims. He made almost no effort to defend himself at trial.

The U.S. military has not carried out the death penalty since 1961. The last widely recognized public execution took place on August 14, 1936. Kentucky, the last state to permit them, outlawed the practice in 1938.

Stay updated on the plans

Also, experts suggest, parents should stay updated on how a livestreamed execution would unfold. Many questions remained unanswered, such as whether the moment of death and its aftermath will be shown, whether any age restrictions will apply, and whether there will be a broadcast delay or a threshold for stopping the feed.

Be informed about the technology involved. While the government often uses YouTube to carry its livestreams, including those embedded within government websites, YouTube prohibits content that is “violent or gory” and “intended to shock or disgust viewers,” and doesn’t allow livestreams that show someone holding, handling, or transporting a firearm.

YouTube does make exceptions in select cases for content it deems to be in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context or that it determines to be in the public’s interest. In such cases, the content may be age-restricted. The company did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding how its policies relate to the execution.

But the danger to kids spills beyond the live broadcast to unexpected exposure on social media in the form of memes, for example.

It’s unclear whether the Trump administration is considering children in its decision-making. Emails over two days asking White House spokespeople for thoughts from the president and first lady Melania Trump on the prospect of children seeing the execution went unanswered. Trump said that he’ll soon make a decision on the plan to livestream the event.

Assume kids will at least hear about the execution, if not see it

From the old-fashioned grapevine to social media, grisly news has a way of reaching school-age children, experts agree. Consider their need for calm and age-appropriate guidance, they suggest.

“With young kids, parents should keep it short and focus on reassurance over explaining the events,” said Jill Murphy, chief content officer at Common Sense Media. “Reassure them that they are safe. With teens, ask honestly what they have heard first, then ask whether they need to watch it.”

Remember you are your child’s parent, not their friend—and don’t overexplain, advises Dr. David Rosenberg, chair of psychiatry and behavioral neurosciences at Wayne State University School of Medicine in Michigan. Answer the questions children ask, and don’t be afraid to assert parental authority by, for example, restricting or banning a child’s access to the footage.

“It’s okay to say, ‘I don’t have all the answers. But here’s what we know, you’re safe, you’re secure, this is what we believe,’” Rosenberg said.

“Where parents get into trouble is when they talk too much, and they usually do that because they’re anxious and insecure,” he added. “What makes a child feel safest, or an adolescent, is can I count on my parents to be calm in challenging situations and give me the information I need?”

Choosing to watch the footage, one physician said, doesn’t necessarily indicate a child is psychologically ready to do so.

Timothy Lesaca, a Pittsburgh-area psychiatrist, cited a series of studies showing that repeatedly watching footage of events like the Boston Marathon bombings, at least part of an ISIS beheading video and the Oklahoma City bombing can be linked to post-traumatic stress, if not PTSD, in adults and children. He argues that making Hasan’s execution public is a medical and public health issue.

“Ongoing anxiety, trouble sleeping or problems with daily life should be taken seriously,” Lesaca wrote on KevinMD, an online publication by physicians.

Watch how this event interacts with existing conditions

The people most at risk of negative long-term effects are those who already have clinical depression or anxiety, or who have already been exposed to other traumatic situations, Rosenberg said. That’s because repeat exposure to trauma can cause cumulative damage.

The part of the brain that handles executive decision-making, emotional regulation, impulsivity, and empathy doesn’t finish developing until around age 24, and so parents should consider having proactive conversations even with their older children who may be away at college or living on their own, Rosenberg said.

“We have to at least offer help in these circumstances to be the leaders, to be the decision-makers, to at least help them make informed decisions.”

—By Laurie Kellman and Rebecca Boone, Associated Press

Associated Press journalist Kaitlyn Huamani contributed to this story.

Bumble stock soars as the embattled dating app strikes deal to go private

1 month ago

Bumble has spent the past few years trying everything from a new CEO to AI-powered matches. 

Now, the embattled dating app company is making another big move: going private.

Ithaca Holdings, a new firm run by former tech executives, is acquiring Bumble for $1.3 billion, the latter announced on Tuesday. Bumble’s board unanimously voted in favor of the deal, with founder and CEO Whitney Wolfe Herd recusing herself from the decision. 

News of a potential deal was first reported by the Wall Street Journal.

Bumble’s shareholders will receive $6.05 for each share of Class A Common Stock. According to Bumble, this is about 138% higher than its Friday, October 9, closing share price and around 119% over its 30-day weighted average price ending Friday. 

The dating app company was valued at about $335 million at the end of business on Friday. 

Ithaca’s co-CEOs and co-founders, Ravi Gupta and John Hegeman, will take over as co-CEOs of Bumble and “partner with Wolfe Herd to extend Bumble’s original vision to help people find connections in life and love into the next era.” 

For anyone wondering what this arrangement might look like, this line in the announcement provides a pretty good idea: “Ithaca’s mission is to apply frontier technology to renew and accelerate businesses that enrich people’s lives and create lasting value in a world transformed by AI.” 

Blackstone, which owns a stake in Bumble, has approved the deal.

Wolfe Herd sang Ithaca’s praises, stating, “In Ithaca, we have found a partner who shares our vision, believes in our women-first mission, and is committed to investing in Bumble’s future.”

Bumble’s journey as a public company

Bumble went public in February 2021, making founder and CEO Whitney Wolfe Herd the youngest woman to take a company public or become a self-made billionaire. It was a success story. 

However, in the five-plus years since, the company has struggled to stay relevant in a world that has grown increasingly tired of dating apps. 

As of October 5, shares of Bumble Inc. (Nasdaq: BMBL) were down almost 95% from their opening high. The stock has had a relatively steady decline over its half a decade of trading. 

That all changed on Monday when news broke of a potential sale. While still over $80 lower than its record high, Bumble’s shares closed up 49.61%. As of publication, the stock has been fluctuating close to 4% up during premarket trading. 

Attempts to stay relevant in recent years

Dating apps of all shapes and sizes have faced a decline as Gen Z, in particular, moves away from online dating. Match Group-owned Hinge is a notable exception to the trend.

Wolfe Herd stepped down as CEO in January 2024, transitioning to the position of executive chair. Her successor, Lidiane Jones—a former Slack CEO—soon cut about 350 roles. 

Jones’s tenure didn’t last very long, with Wolfe Herd returning as CEO in March 2025.

A few months later, Bumble cut another 240 positions, about 30% of its workforce. Shortly after, Wolfe Herd threatened to remove “members with low-quality and incomplete profiles” in a focus on quality over quantity. 

Bumble has also paid attention to its non-romantic ventures. In November 2025, the company launched a new standalone BFF app.

Like many tech CEOs, Wolfe Herd has turned to AI as a potential draw for users. In May, Bumble launched an AI assistant called Bee. Bumble calls Bee a matchmaker, with the tool meant to replace the need to swipe. The company is also testing out having Bee create dates for matches. 

Then, in August, Bumble announced it would be getting rid of its distinguishing feature: women messaging first. 

The company cited a 2024 internal survey that found two-thirds of women felt less pressure around dating when men made the first move. At the time, the company launched its Opening Move feature, which allowed men to make the first move using preset prompts and gave women 24 hours to respond or the match expired. 

Now, anyone can message and users have 72 hours to respond. 

“Today, our community is asking for more flexibility, less pressure, and more opportunities to create real, meaningful connections and that is what this new experience provides,” Wolfe Herd said in the announcement. “This evolution isn’t a departure from our founding vision, but the realization of it.”

Character.ai has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection as it moves to sell assets to Disney

1 month ago

Controversial chatbot platform Character.ai is seeking Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the wake of mounting legal challenges and runaway operating costs, the four-year-old startup said in a surprise announcement on Monday.

The move comes as the Menlo Park, California, company has faced a number of lawsuits in recent years, including some that say its AI companions have encouraged users to harm or kill themselves.

In its announcement, Character.ai said it has reached an agreement with Disney Worldwide Services, an affiliate of the Walt Disney Company, to sell some of its intellectual property for $20 million and “transition services” that will help Character.ai continue to operate, at least temporarily.

Disney will serve as a “stalking horse” bidder in the Chapter 11 proceedings, meaning other companies could offer competing bids.

Fast Company reached out to Disney for comment.

“Over the past year, Character.ai has taken meaningful steps to sustain and improve its business in the face of significant legal, regulatory, and operational headwinds,” CEO Colin Adams said in a statement. “After a comprehensive review of the available alternatives, the board determined that this court-supervised sale process provides the Company with the best opportunity to maximize value for all stakeholders.”

In a blog post, the company said its platform “remains up and running” as it seeks to figure out a path forward. It expects the sale process to be completed by November or early December.

This story is developing…

38 Percent of U.S. adults are estranged from family. The workplace is feeling it

1 month ago

Family estrangement isn’t just a private family problem anymore. It’s become a widely discussed social phenomenon. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, reports and polls across the United States have pointed to a rise in adults cutting ties with relatives. 

The subject is everywhere: on social media, on talk shows, and in conversations with friends who are navigating increasingly complicated family dynamics. 

A 2020 Cornell University study by sociologist Karl Pillemer offered a striking pre-pandemic baseline: 27 percent of American adults—roughly 67 million people — reported being estranged from a relative. 

The numbers now appear even higher. A comprehensive 2025 YouGov poll found that 38 percent of U.S. adults reported being estranged from at least one close family member.

While researchers caution that long-term longitudinal data is still limited, psychologists point to pandemic-era stress, political polarization, and changing cultural norms as factors that may have accelerated family ruptures and made no contact an increasingly familiar choice. 

Family ruptures quietly seep into the workplace

The estimated total of all mental health challenges in the workforce costs U.S. businesses $47.6 billion annually in lost productivity, according to Gallup. 

Businesses started paying meaningful attention to employee mental health in the 1980s and 1990s, but it became a major mainstream business priority around 2020–22, largely because of the pandemic, burnout, anxiety, and remote-work disruption.

Because the workplace is where most adults spend much of their waking hours, the effects of family estrangement don’t necessarily stay at home. The grief and trauma can drain attention, leadership capacity, creativity, productivity, and ultimately, the company’s bottom line. 

Presenteeism is on the rise 

Have you ever felt like you were talking to someone who was physically in the room with you, but their mind was somewhere else? Employees dealing with the emotional fallout of estrangement often suffer from presenteeism at work—physically present but not mentally there in the moment. 

Chronic stress, grief, and anxiety that come with family estrangement can lead to significant deficits in cognitive energy and output. This brain drain can also heighten irritability, weaken focus on demanding work, and cause critical meetings and deadlines to be missed. 

Heightened emotional strain, especially near holidays 

The workplace can often feel like a second home, especially if you are close with your co-workers. The office also tends to mirror societal norms and expectations around family, especially during major holiday seasons at year-end.  

Office small talk about holiday plans and family vacations can be a constant emotional trigger. This environment can cause estranged employees to experience spikes in anxiety, depression, and social withdrawal—temporarily lowering team morale and engagement.

Increased absenteeism and health care costs 

The chronic, long-term stress of family trauma can often manifest physically. Estranged individuals frequently report higher rates of insomnia, fatigue, autoimmune flare-ups, and mental health crises.

For businesses, this can lead to unplanned consecutive days off, higher PTO or short-term disability use, and increased health insurance premiums. 

Confusing professional relationships 

The psychological dynamics of family estrangement can sometimes bleed into professional environments without realizing it. Adults who have cut ties with family members, for whatever reasons, may struggle with authority figures or conflict resolution in the office. They can overreact to constructive feedback, take things too personally, and even refuse to ask for help when they need it.  

These issues can create unspoken problems between colleagues, which can lead to unsolved problems at scale. 

When family crisis shows up at work

I spoke with David Simonse of Creative Solutions Counseling Solutions about when a private family crisis becomes an employer’s business. 

“When work is being impacted negatively by a family crisis, then an employer should step in carefully and respectfully,” he explained. “Ultimately, they should see whether they can be helpful and to determine whether there is a risk to the business itself.” 

Simonse noted that while HR can help employees navigate some family crises, it can’t address every situation. He suggested that companies broaden family leave beyond traditional milestones like birth or death, giving employees more flexibility to manage serious personal crises before they affect their work and morale. 

As he puts it, talking with HR about “how it impacts their work would be a good start.” 

Compassion has a business case 

Employers cannot repair families. However, they can use their resources on-hand and find the compassion to best support their employees in such challenging times. 

A workforce that carries unresolved family loss has thinner reserves. The cost is paid in missed ideas, thinner leadership, and quiet quitting—numbers that compound long after the last work meeting.

—Robyn D. Shulman

This article originally appeared on Fast Company’s sister website, Inc.com. 

Inc. is the voice of the American entrepreneur. We inspire, inform, and document the most fascinating people in business: the risk-takers, the innovators, and the ultra-driven go-getters that represent the most dynamic force in the American economy.

5 clever ways to break through writer’s block

1 month ago

This article is republished with permission from Wonder Tools, a newsletter that helps you discover the most useful sites and apps.

Once you start scribbling a few sentences, you’re on your way.

Having gotten stuck and unstuck a lot over the past 325 weeks of writing this newsletter, I’ve found a few tricks that help. Pick one to try, and leave a comment to share what you do to get unstuck.

As a little experiment, I’ve made an Unstuck Studio page to accompany this post and to help you get unstuck playfully.

As Daniel Pink explains, starting comes first: “Action precedes motivation,” he says, “not the other way around.”

Talk first, type later

When I’m stuck, I dictate rather than battle my inner critic.

The critic assumes there’s a better word for whatever I’m typing. It urges my fingers to stop and wait. When I’m rambling with my voice, the critic is quiet.

We call an idea freeze writer’s block, not talker’s block. When we speak informally, ideas just flow. Because spoken words disappear into air, it’s easier to avoid self-editing. In a dictated draft, clunky first words are OK because they get us closer to what we’re trying to convey.

Tools I use for dictating first drafts
  1. Google Docs voice typing works in more than 100 languages. In English you can add punctuation verbally or say things like “new paragraph.” See more of my favorite Google Docs tips and tricks. Free.
  2. Letterly works well on mobile or desktop. In addition to transcribing, it can give you a summary or format your text. (It’s now a free perk for paid Wonder Tools subscribers.) Free with limits, or $80/year.
  3. Wispr Flow lets me dictate into any app or site on my laptop or phone. It works surprisingly well even if I whisper, which helps around other people. I just double tap my Mac function key and start talking. Free to start; $12/month for pro features.
  4. Lispr.ai is a reliable Mac option. It can also translate your dictation. Free.
  5. Simple alternatives: iOS Voice Memos and Notes transcribe your speech for free. On Android, try Google Keep.
Write it or lose it

The Most Dangerous Writing App erases your words if you stop typing before your timer ends. Choose a 3- or 5-minute sprint, or set a word target. Once you get the hang of it, your hands will keep moving. Edit later. Free

Ilys is an even more challenging way to force yourself to keep writing. It shows your typing just one letter at a time. When your session is over, you can review and edit your words. Free for basic use. Sessions are capped at 808 words, which is more than enough for freewriting. A subscription is $11/month, but I don’t need the extras.

One word, then a web

Mind maps help you focus on concepts and ideas, rather than piling words onto the page. Connect your ideas to one another visually. Put one word down. Add a picture if you want. Pretty soon you have an outline to build on.

When I’m writing something complex or juggling lots of ideas, mind mapping allows me to assemble the bones of a piece efficiently. Use Apple’s free Freeform app on iOS or Mac. Or try simple apps like Mindmup or Bubbl.us. Both are free for up to three maps. Miro and Mural, which offer more advanced design features, also give you three free boards.

AI for provocation

Rather than using AI to write, ask it to interview you. Or push it to provoke you. I find that helps me surface my own thoughts.

Prompts to try
  • “Interview me about this. Ask one question at a time. Push me for depth.”
  • “Provoke me. Give me a controversial statement to respond to.”
  • “Push me to sharpen my viewpoint by pointing out potential blind spots in the ideas I’m starting to write about.”
  • “Ask me five intriguing questions about this. Don’t answer any of them.”
  • “Act as a tough mentor. Give me five unconventional writing prompts to pick from.”
  • “Ask a surprising question I’ve not heard before. Include a feasible writing target to complete in the next 10 minutes.”
8 boxes, 8 minutes

This last tactic is tech-free.

  • Grab a piece of blank paper.
  • Fold it in half three times. You now have 8 rectangles.
  • Challenge yourself to put one sentence or phrase into each of the boxes. Set a timer to repeat every minute. Move to the next box each time it rings. Eight minutes later, you have a bunch of sentences to build on.

Slogans tell us that discipline propels people toward accomplishments. That sounds logical. But when I’m staring at a cursor, discipline alone doesn’t clear the fog. These tactics do.

This article is republished with permission from Wonder Tools, a newsletter that helps you discover the most useful sites and apps.

Chipotle’s ridiculously oversized bag can carry enough food to feed your entire family

1 month ago

Chipotle Mexican Grill has debuted a 3-foot-wide, 170-liter (45-gallon) bag that serves as both a bold fashion statement and a marketing stunt that exemplifies the creative style of its chief brand officer, Fernando Machado.

Within the span of just seven weeks, Machado has rolled out three creative campaigns that point to a buzzier, more social media-friendly approach that intends to lure diners to the brand’s 4,200 restaurants.

On Tuesday, the company debuted its “Big Ass Chipotle Bag,” a limited-edition accessory that will star in a national advertising campaign to promote the company’s family meal kits.

This follows a campaign that featured footage from 100 content creators, which debuted in August and was the first national ad spot from Machado since he joined Chipotle in June. Earlier in October, Chipotle unveiled a new music track recorded by a vegetable orchestra (yes, really!) at London’s Abbey Road Studios.

“Evolving brand messaging, in my mind, is not a total disruption with what has been done in the past,” Machado tells Fast Company.

Machado says his plan is to push the boundaries of creativity for Chipotle’s messaging, while also retaining the food-and-ingredient-focused ethos that gave the brand a distinctive voice in the restaurant sector. He has vowed to avoid making any sweeping changes to the branding, logos, or taglines, moves he says are mistakes frequently made by new chief marketing officers.

A page out of fashion’s book

This week’s “Big Ass Chipotle Bag” campaign takes a cue from the oversized bag trend that’s become a hit on runways and has been embraced by major luxury brands, including Chanel and Bottega Veneta.

“This is a brand that’s very wholesome, that’s trying to do the right thing, and wants to put a smile on people’s faces,” says Machado. “It’s not laugh-out-loud, but it’s joyful, it’s playful.”

Machado joined Chipotle as the company is in the early stages of a turnaround effort after four consecutive quarters of traffic declines at its restaurants throughout 2025.

[Photo: Chipotle]

In February, Chipotle’s CEO, Scott Boatwright, announced a “Recipe for Growth” strategy that committed to accelerating menu innovations, evolving the brand’s messaging, strengthening operations at the restaurants, and leaning more on artificial intelligence. 

Early indications are that diners are coming back to the Chipotle fold. Comparable restaurant sales have improved modestly for the first two quarters of 2026 compared with last year’s levels, driven by an increase in traffic. The company’s third-quarter results are to be released on October 28. 

Yet another business consideration for Machado and Chipotle’s leadership is a Financial Times report last week that Starbucks—now led by Chipotle’s former CEO, Brian Niccol—had been mulling a $41 billion merger with Chipotle that would be the largest-ever takeover in the restaurant sector. Niccol is spearheading his own two-year turnaround effort at Starbucks. (The coffee chain has since said it is “not buying Chipotle.”)

More evolution than turnaround

Historically at Chipotle, creative campaigns have focused on ingredients and food sourcing, including 2011’s “Back to the Start” and 2013’s “The Scarecrow,” both well-reviewed animated short films that lambasted industrial farming practices.

[Photos: Chipotle]

In 2018, Chipotle debuted its “For Real” campaign that lauded the chain’s “real” ingredients, and a year later, “Behind the Foil” focused on the chain’s employees and kitchen operations.

“I don’t think this is a brand that’s in need of a turnaround,” says Machado of Chipotle’s past creative work, which he says helped make it a fast-growing restaurant concept. “This is a brand, just like any other brand that’s successful, that needs to evolve.”

Before joining Chipotle, Machado spent more than seven years as the chief marketing officer at Restaurant Brands International across brands like Burger King and Popeyes. He also held the CMO title at the plant-based food company NotCo and the video game developer Activision Blizzard.

He has established a reputation for buzzy, stunt-forward campaigns like the “Moldy Whopper.” That campaign depicted Burger King’s signature menu item going moldy, but framed the gross, decaying imagery as a positive sign, because the chain had removed all artificial preservatives.

At Chipotle, Machado says he’s keeping a fresh eye on how conversations have evolved on social channels, where younger Gen Z and Gen Alpha diners are more inclined to express their opinions.

Brands, he says, are “better defined by what people talk about on social, rather than what the brand asserts about itself on TV.”

[Photo: Chipotle]

Accordingly, Machado let content creators go into the kitchens at more than 50 restaurants to work alongside Chipotle’s workers as they prepared the company’s new limited-edition Pollo Asado and Chili Lime Chips.

There was no script and no shot list, and Chipotle’s own marketing team submitted not a single shot of brand footage in the campaign that ran across national TV, TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts.

“They know their audience better than you do,” says Machado. “I know it may sound a bit nerve-racking to give away control, but that’s what we did.”

Earlier in October, Chipotle embraced a whimsical and irreverent campaign that also leaned on the company’s “real” ingredient messaging with the original track “From Ground to Sound,” which featured playable instruments including flutes made from corn and trumpets built using jalapeños. 

“We want to do things that stand out, that get people to talk about the brand,” says Machado. “I think you can only do that if you do something that’s different and unique—and also hopefully only something that your brand can do.”

Graphic design isn’t dying. It’s expanding

1 month ago

It’s a liberating time to be a graphic designer. You would think so, anyway, after reading Jarrett Fuller’s new book, Graphic Designers After Graphic Design, published this fall by Princeton Architectural Press.

Fuller, a designer, writer, podcaster, and professor at North Carolina State University, makes an optimistic case for an expansive definition of graphic design. Through conversations with practitioners working across publishing, research, changemaking, performance, and artistic practice, he argues that graphic design is much more than the production of posters, logos, and websites. 

Coinciding with the 10th anniversary of his podcast, Scratching the Surface, which highlights practitioners overlapping with graphic design, the book turns its attention specifically to graphic designers with expansive, blurry, and very public practices. 

[Image: Courtesy Princeton Architectural Press]

As fellow design educators, Fuller and I caught up about what this broader understanding of design means for the current generation of graphic designers. As he puts it, graphic designers are inherently insecure about their discipline’s identity and relevance. But rather than trying to resolve that uncertainty, what if we embraced it? We talked about the confidence it takes to define a practice on your own terms, and the possibilities that open up when you do. Below is a conversation we had over Zoom, which was edited for clarity.

Nika Simovich Fisher: Congratulations on your book—I really enjoyed the expansive, blurry multidisciplinary model of all of the perspectives. I think it’s important to have an optimistic perspective right now.

In class yesterday, I had a sophomore student ask me if, in my opinion, right now is a good time to go into the interaction design field. I thought of your book immediately because it does a great job of encapsulating how design can be part of many different realms, and I responded in that way. But I also did hear her anxiety, and I was curious, how would you have responded to her?

Jarrett Fuller: Yeah, I mean, look, that’s a great question, and not to make this too much about the book right away, because I know you’re asking generally. But I think one of the arguments that I’m making, and one of the very real experiences of my life, and I’m sure your life also, is that it’s kind of never a good time to go into design.

It’s always at risk. There’s always something that is threatening to kill it or to take it away from us. That’s the first thing I would say: There’s always an existential risk. There has always been an existential risk, but whatever that new thing is that’s supposed to kill it means that we get to make it something new. We get to find some new way to practice it.

One of the things—I think this is a line explicitly in the book—is that every generation gets to redefine design for themselves. The design of tomorrow is different from the design of yesterday. That’s really scary, and I’ve been there, but it’s also always been like that. So instead of trying to avoid that, let’s just embrace it. Let’s figure out what it could be together and where it could go next, as opposed to abandoning it.

I think that’s the optimism that you’re talking about. I feel like I’ve gone through all these cycles of grief for design, and I’m kind of just over it now. Let’s just make it what we want it to be. That’s so much more fun.

[Image: Courtesy Princeton Architectural Press]

Absolutely. It’s very freeing in that sense. I have a research assistant this semester, and at our meeting today, she was wearing a shirt that she picked up at the Printed Matter book fair that said, “Print is dead.” It was really funny and brilliant because it’s this throwaway line that we’ve heard since we were in school. And yet here we are, talking about your book that came out in print just the other day.

Right. It’s true. I heard that when I was in school, which is 15 years ago now, and it persists somehow.

It’s an interesting answer, but it’s not the right question, I guess. It’s not about print, or design, going away or not, but things changing, knowing that they’re going to change, and having the skills to lean into that friction. That’s what I took away from a lot of the respondents in your book.

I want to add to that because I think you’re right. That is where the anxiety comes from: this sense that design is really hard to define and is always changing, always different. There are questions of, well, what is design history, and who gets to be included? Why are there not more venues to write about design? All of this is just laddering up to this thing of: Are we actually a real thing? Is graphic design a real discipline?

I actually think we should embrace that blurriness as opposed to complaining about it, living in fear of it, or trying to put walls up around it in some way.

I 100% agree, maybe that’s more honest, too. It’s noteworthy that we’re both professors at universities. At yours, you’re a professor of “graphic and experience design,” and I’m one of “communication design”—singular communication, not the plural, as you pointed out in the book. It’s interesting that we’re able to talk about the same things. We’re teaching similar classes and can trade notes, but technically they’re qualified in these other words.

Yeah, what is that? I don’t even know what all those different terms mean anymore. That’s another thread in the book: Because we don’t know what we are, we don’t know what we do, because we always feel like we’re at risk, we’re always trying to come up with new names. Maybe that’s the wrong question. Finding a term to define it doesn’t actually do anything because then that term is just at risk of all the problems of the last term in some way.

Once you claim it as something, then you’re kind of saying it’s not other things. But in this book in particular, you’re saying that publishing, research, change making, performance, and artistic practice are actually all parts of graphic design, too.

I really enjoyed those categories. Were there other candidates as well? How did you land on those?

That’s a surprisingly hard question. Yes, there were others, and those emerged through the writing process, through the research process, and through the interviews. As I was trying to figure out how to group people, those were really broad categories that could contain a lot.

One of the challenges in the book is that a lot of the people I feature could sit between those categories or could sit in different sections. So there was a lot of zooming in and out: How broad should these categories be versus how specific?

Early on there was a version with film and video, but then that fell aside. One thing I tried to avoid was including other design fields.

The final categories span the production process. It’s everything from the creation of original ideas all the way to giving that knowledge shape or form, to the distribution of those forms out into the world. It’s taking design out of that sliver of image-making or visual production, and it’s moving it to both sides: to the production of the ideas, and then also the distribution of those ideas. I think those together made for this nice process of communication, if you will.

I think you had written that in the book too, this idea of making it public becomes part of it. On that note, this morning I got your [email] newsletter. You were talking about releasing the book and how there’s this time gap between finishing writing the book and now seeing it come to fruition. Does it feel like a new chapter of this project?

Yeah, it does. When I saw the final PDFs, and then when I saw the printed one, it was like, great, this is the book now. Now on to the next thing. And now that I’m actually talking to people who have read it, it’s opening up new readings for me and helping me see the book in a new way. It is that idea of making it public, of putting it out into the world, and that actually continues the creative process in some way.

The other thing I was worried about—worried is a strong word—was, how is the world going to be different by the time this book comes out? When I knew it was done, and then when I saw what the publication date was, it’s like, is this still going to be relevant? Are these topics still interesting?

I think they’re more relevant than I realized. That existential threat that your student felt at the beginning of this conversation, I think that’s more front of mind for people. Not just for students, but also practicing designers and design professors are all wondering, what are we doing here, and how do we make sense of it? Hopefully this book is a way to give some shape, or some map, or some ideas of how to push some of these ideas forward in 2026, with everything going on in the world.

By distributing it in the format you did, it felt quite formal and educational, almost like a textbook. Was that your intention?

Yes and no. When I was working on it, I was really thinking, this is a book for students who are studying graphic design, to show them a really diverse range of practices that you can have with the skills that you’re learning.

There’s a really broad, diverse range of practices that one can do after they have studied graphic design, with the language and the methods and the skills of graphic design. In that sense, thinking about it as a textbook, sure, I like that reading. It’s very much a map of what you can do.

On the other hand, one of the reasons why I wanted to feature real designers who are all what I call emerging and midcareer—so they’re all [about] 40 and younger, basically a book of millennials—is that when you talk about the future of graphic design, or alternative ways of practicing graphic design, or what graphic design can be, that can get really theoretical and speculative really fast.

Especially when you talk to students about it and say, “Oh, you can do this kind of stuff, there’s no way to actually comprehend how you turn that into a practice.” I really wanted to root this in real people who are actually doing it and talk to them, some of them very candidly, about where the money comes from. How do you fund these projects? To show that this isn’t just an idea of graphic design. There are real people who are doing it like this today.

They all have active practices that fit into this discipline of graphic design that could be academic, but also is very much engaged with the public.

Right, exactly. You said it better than I did. I also wondered if a book was the right format for something like this. In some ways, I also wanted it to be a record of right now. Who are these people right now? How are they thinking about their work in this moment, in this generation? In the future, we can look at it and say, here’s how a bunch of people thought about graphic design in 2026. There’s also a historical thing that I think a book is still kind of the best at.

And with a book, you can notice little details within it. For example, I appreciated that the birth years of the interviewees were prominently listed in the margins. I think the oldest person was born in 1978 and the youngest in 1998.

Yeah, that was the thing. I pushed my editors on that. They weren’t totally sure they wanted to do that, and I was like, I really want this to be a generational argument. I want to show that this is a cohort of people who maybe don’t know each other, who are maybe not in dialogue with each other, but they all are coming through a similar system and are saying something about what it’s like to make graphic design right now.

Everybody who I’ve talked to about the book has commented on the birth dates in there. I’m really happy that you like that.

I do. I like that it’s not the traditional years for millennials or Gen Z. It’s a little blurry, which supports the argument.

Outside of their ages, something else all the people in the book have in common, is that they really are making a design career work. It was Silvio Lorusso who was talking about testing out design ideas and doing these speaking opportunities to support it. You said it’s like the stand-up comedy approach to graphic design, and I loved that so much. One, it was funny, but two, there was something really relatable to hear these other people validate this way of working and say, this is where I’m testing out ideas, and I get to distribute my work organically, and that’s still design.

There’s two things that I would say about that. One, I also love that moment, and I didn’t want the book to be a how-to book. I didn’t want it to be, here’s how you work outside of a studio system or a startup system. I didn’t want to go through that, but I did want there to be references to how people make it work.

The idea of, I will give a lot of talks, and that money gives me space so that I can sit and write a book. But that also gives me an audience that I can test these ideas with for when I go to write the book. Or talking to Nicole Killian, who has this publishing practice, and they get grants from their university that they put toward publishing the work of other artists. They have this ratio of what they bring to book fairs so they can be sure that money will come back to them. All that’s embedded in there sort of secretly, without being explicitly a how-to book.

[Image: Courtesy Princeton Architectural Press]

But then, in some ways, I’m also a millennial. I’m also part of this cohort. The book was a way for me to validate what I’m doing. I come from graphic design, but like you, do stuff that doesn’t really look like graphic design. Being in dialogue with these people was also a way to put my work, that sometimes can feel isolating, into some sort of larger cohort or generational thing.

The podcast, the writing that I do for Fast Company and other places, are all ways to test out these ideas. Then they go back into the classroom, or the classroom goes out into an essay. They’re all testing out the same ideas in different places.

What you said about writing reminds me of two of the conversations in the book. First, Tiger Dingsun was talking about how in poetry, you see the interior of the person, but in design you do not. Similarly, Silvio Lorusso was talking about how writing and design to him are not the same. He said that design is all about being straightforward, getting to the point, and writing has more romance, essentially.

Is that something you thought about, as you were writing your book?

That’s a really good question. I’m conflicted about it because I understand both of their arguments, and I think the argument that I’m trying to make is a “yes, and” argument. Yes, I agree with that, but can’t design also be like that too?

Why do we say design has to be efficient and immediate and trying to sell you something, or trying to communicate something in a clear way? Why can’t design be poetry? I want graphic design that’s more poetry and less graphic design that’s problem-solving, in some way. I think the collection of people here are trying to make that case: It can be both. It doesn’t just have to be the commercial, efficient, market-capital way we think about graphic design.

All too often, we let the profession and the industry win out, and this other stuff, the cultural side of it, gets pushed to the side and is seen as outside of graphic design or alternative. Or we call it something else. This isn’t graphic design because it’s not doing these other things, so we’re going to call this art or fine art or studio practice.

I’m trying to have a big umbrella for graphic design, to say it can include all of those things, and it does include all those things. So why do we keep segmenting them out as different?

There’s a really interesting thread of a lot of the people I talked to had a similar experience of waffling between feeling optimistic about design, then constricting, and finding ways to make it work. Many tried to get away from design, and then came back to it with a bigger understanding of it.

I love that that is a theme, and it’s something that’s very relatable if you are working in this blurry state of design. In your book, Nicole Killian also talked about how they wouldn’t be able to do the work they’re doing now without having the design knowledge. It’s an empowering narrative.

It seems that for many, design becomes this psychological process, which feels very honest and relatable. In Mindy Seu’s section, she talks about finding the thing that you think about obsessively. I really loved it when she said that after graduating undergrad and studying design, her peers were getting these design jobs, and she felt like, why am I not doing that type of work?

Then she saw that her peers were more interested in form, and she realized that was never her thing. She leaned into what she does naturally, which is gathering resources. I appreciated that part of the conversation because it shows that we’re all different, and we all have different strengths. In your book they’re all valid options.

Right, and why do we have to say that one is right and one is wrong? I think that’s the tension that Mindy’s talking about. You see these people getting these quote-unquote good jobs, and you think you’re supposed to be doing that, and it’s actually much more pluralistic.

That’s where the book is very biographical for me too. I wanted to be a designer for a really long time. I go and study it, and then I get my first job as a graphic designer in New York, thinking I’d made it. I just didn’t like it. I was like, oh, this is not as interesting. There were all these other parts of design that were also interesting to me, and there was no space for that in those types of jobs.

I had to find new ways to keep doing the thing that I was doing, but in different sorts of contexts. That’s Mindy. I mean, that’s everybody. That is the book. It’s to show that that’s not a departure from design. It’s an expansion of graphic design.

Just now when you said “bioGRAPHICAL” I’m reminded of the suffix—graphical—you articulated in the book. I didn’t know that that word came from both to draw and write together, which is so perfect.


Yeah, that’s my big surprise in the book. That’s the thing that I feel explains everything that comes before it. We think of graphic design as visual. We think of “graphic” in graphic design as visual, but that’s actually a very limited definition of that word.

As we’re talking about all these different paths for design, I’m noticing there is a lot of confidence in deciding, “Okay, I’m going to do this my way.” Everyone in the book does it. You can make an argument that any working creative person has made the decision to do it their way, but it’s hard to communicate that to students or designers earlier in their journey.

There is a lot of risk in choosing to do these things that are unconventional, or at least, not a one-to-one path you can follow. What about design education could help people make that leap?

I have a couple ways that maybe I would answer that. Graphic design education—whether that’s communication design or graphic and experience, whatever the subterms are, this shared world that we’re both in—there is often, in many programs, by necessity, an immediate need to create focus areas. Are you going to focus on branding? Are you going to focus on interaction? When I was in school, literally, when you got to your junior year, it was, are you going to be a print designer or a web designer? Then you just took classes in one of those. I think we should encourage much more commingling of these and much more multidisciplinary thinking.

Graphic design is medium-agnostic. It’s not actually about the medium that is the end result. It’s not about the book or the website or the logo or the painting or the film. It’s about all the ideas, and then how those ideas take a shape.

What would design education look like that more about, how do you give ideas form? Those forms can take any form. More of that early, less about outputs and more about process, and that shift from idea to form, is one way to start doing that.

The second is to—and I hesitate to say this—not be so tied to industry. Not to look at what the jobs that companies are hiring for, but to actually lead that in some way and say, here are the types of skills that we think are important as educators. Let’s feed that into the students, and then let industry respond to that.

I think that will create more confidence. That will create more entrepreneurial-type students because you’re building things on your own while you’re in school.

The last piece is that design education could have much more space for self-reflection. There should be work that you are making in response to things, but there should be almost a metapractice. What are the things you’re interested in? What’s the type of practice you want to have? How do we create spaces for you to try that and test those things while you’re in school, while you’re in a safe space, while you have the time to think about the kind of work you want to make, so you can start building on that?

When you graduate, you have a body of work that is not just making you employable, but is also saying something about you and the type of practice that you want to have. How do we build that into curriculums, right from the beginning?

I love that and agree. Those questions inherently build confidence, because you have to put something out into the world and stand behind it. To have it result in a form, you have to go through various decisions and side quests to finish it.

I think it’s a way to be a creative person in the age of AI also. If design is medium-agnostic and it’s not actually about the form of the thing or the medium of the thing, AI can do that. You can tell AI, make me a book with this kind of layout. Make me an app with this sort of thing. Make me a logo that looks like this. That’s the easy part now. The actual production of it is done.

What designers have to do is have a point of view, a set of ideas, be able to have a thing that they want to say that only they can say. That’s the stuff AI can’t do.

I was going to say that I like that your book doesn’t explicitly talk about AI, but it’s between the lines in a lot of things. What Nat Pyper was saying about being in grad school and figuring out how to make this work that they think should exist, and using design to get it out—I think that’s it right there. That’s really what AI cannot do. For example, AI cannot make that series of letterforms inspired by queer counterculture.

Right. Somebody who read the book said the message of the book is, “Make design weird again.” I think that’s kind of true. All of the standard stuff is the stuff that AI is going to take first, so we need to lean into the weirdness, the humanness, the strange, the stuff that only we can communicate. That’s a great example of that, and that conversation is a great case study in that.

[Image: Courtesy Princeton Architectural Press]


I love “Make graphic design weird again,” I think Santa Cruz, California, has a similar slogan. Maybe we can borrow it.

One of the other questions I had was about a sense of humor in design. It’s related to our conversation about confidence, but knowing about visual forms and what they communicate and having control over it, allows you to make jokes in a way that people who aren’t as versed in that, can’t. Nat brought up the idea of being a jester, for example, and Nicole Killian’s project was called, “Come to my window,” a pun inspired by the ’90s song.

There’s this sense of play, along with the stand-up comedy approach to sharing work. There’s all those examples of breaking the script in the book. Like, Silvio literally said not using a script for PowerPoints. The thing that connects a lot of these practitioners is the willingness to be seen and to be energetic and funny.

That’s really smart. What that’s making me think of is, so much of our visual culture just looks the same. There’s so much copying. Every time there’s a rebrand, it looks like a thing that we’ve seen before. Every app on our phone basically looks exactly the same and has the same set of interaction patterns. You can go to any city and see similar-looking buildings. This is Kyle Chayka’s idea of airspace: All the coffee shops look the same.

It doesn’t have to be like that. The people in this book are maybe the extreme cases of that, but that doesn’t mean these ideas can’t actually make their way back into commercial design practices. That humor, that personality, that strangeness, that disorientation, that friction, that poetics—why can’t that be part of a brand or part of an app or part of a space?

I sometimes feel like the people in this book I’m describing are very different, but I think all that is a way to signal where all of this could go. It’s not just that you have to leave traditional graphic design practice. You can take these ideas and embed them into the work that you’re already doing also.

Then it goes back to that multidisciplinary model, and also being realistic, because it is an expensive world that we live in. Having diverse models of taking your skill set and applying it is useful.

Yeah, diverse models, and I would say diverse scales also. So often we think, in a globalized world, that everything has to reach everybody.

This idea that you can have a small practice and a small cohort, a small public—not everything has to be global—is an interesting way to think about this moment also. What is the scale of the practice that you want? I don’t really talk about that in the book specifically, but there’s questions underlying a lot of these conversations.

Again, that feels very empowering to me. What it touches on is, essentially, how do you define success, whether within graphic design or personally? All of these people are chosen partially because of their professional track record. There’s something refreshing about seeing how everyone interpreted that for their own practice.

Yeah, I think that’s right.

In terms of AI, did you intentionally not want to talk about it or was it just not a priority? Do you think the conversations were a reaction to AI without needing to spell it out?

I didn’t want to write about it. I didn’t want this to be an AI book. Going back to your very first question, there’s always something that design is reacting to, and if it’s not AI, it will be something else.

In some ways, this book is reacting to a bunch of things. It’s reacting to AI. It’s probably reacting to the Trump presidency and the reordering of the world order. It’s probably reacting to the 2008 financial crisis, which a lot of these people graduated into. It’s reacting to Brexit for a lot of the people that I spoke to in Europe. There are a lot of things that are informing all of this.

My interest was not in what we were reacting to, but in what we were making next. This is really a book about people, and maybe that also is the subtle way that this is a reaction to AI: these are people who are doing things. The book is called Graphic Designers After Graphic Design. Who are these designers? Maybe that’s a subtle protest of AI too.

In the foreword, Ellen Lupton writes about mistaking the title of your book for Graphic Design After Graphic Designers, which is a very different reading and much more apocalyptic. She wrote about it better than I’m articulating, but it preserves your hopeful perspective, or why at least it felt optimistic to me.

Optimistic is right. It’s very much a celebration. I write this in the beginning: I feel like graphic designers are really insecure people. We, as an industry, as a discipline, don’t feel respected. We feel like there’s always people outside of design who think that they can do it. It’s hard to actually describe what it is that we do.

You’ve used this word a couple times, and I really like it: confidence. This is a book about saying we should actually own all of those things. We should own the fact that this is really hard to define. We should own the fact that no one quite understands what it is. We should own the fact that everyone else thinks that they can do it also. We should own the fact that it’s always changing.

Let’s call ourselves graphic designers again. We don’t have to run from that. If you want to make paintings, if you want to make films, if you want to write essays, if you want to do any of these things, why can’t that be graphic design too? At the end of the day, that’s all this book is trying to do. It’s trying to say all of these things can be graphic design.

This cool interactive visual argues that generative art began in a cave

1 month ago

Around 71,000 BCE, someone in a place now called Blombos Cave, on the southern coast of what is now South Africa, scratched crosshatched lines into a piece of ocher. No computer. No code. No prompt. But according to The Living Timeline, launched by digital art institution Le Random, the drawing is a work of generative art, just like your latest AI-styled photo on Instagram.

The Living Timeline is an interactive history of generative art, with 1,147 moments running from 71,000 BCE to 2026 that cover artworks, ideas, and exhibitions connected to the human-made algorithms and machines that made them possible. It includes examples as disparate as those primitive etchings, the 1804 invention of the jacquard loom, and a video processor from 1974.

According to Peter Bauman, editor-in-chief at Le Random, the timeline “helps explain to people outside of the space why certain works are important.” He believes you can’t judge 1960s plotter art by its appearance alone, for example, because “you also have to consider the context, and how difficult every single thing they were doing at the time was.”

Bauman wrote The Living Timeline with contributions from Sasha Stiles—a Kalmyk American poet and AI researcher—and Vuk Ćosić, a Slovenian pioneer of the 1990s net.art movement known for his ASCII-based work.

[Screenshot: Le Random]

Take those 73,000-year-old crosshatched lines in the Blombos Cave, the first known drawing by humans and the first entry in the timeline. According to art theorist Philip Galanter, professor emeritus at the Texas A&M University College of Performance, Visualization & Fine Arts, “They qualify as generative because the placement of individual marks has not been decided by the artisan, but dictated by a manually executed symmetry‐based algorithm.”

Galanter’s definition of generative art—published in a research paper in 2003—strongly influenced Bauman’s own definition, which in turn influenced the timeline. Generative art is an art practice in which an artist uses a system (natural-language rules, a computer program, a machine, or another procedural method) that contributes to or completes the work. 

[Screenshot: Le Random]

Galanter’s thesis that generative art “is as old as art itself” is a provocative, but solid, idea. Still, it doesn’t mean that all art is generative.

To know what’s generative you have to ask a simple question: Did the artist give a rule, process, material, or machine some room to make decisions? The timeline does that, connecting generative art to looms, music composed with dice, code-controlled plotters, and neural networks. The artist creates a system, and if the system helps or makes something, that’s generative art. 

By that general rule, however, I can see many different rules or algorithms used to create art through the ages, from the realism provided by the perspective grids and optical mirrors that dictated the appearance of a masterwork like Diego Velázquez’s Las Meninas to the strict geometric and chromatic limits rules set by Piet Mondrian for his de Stijl-style paintings.

[Screenshot: Le Random] AI has joined the chat

Perhaps that’s why the timeline is so useful at this moment in history, as a tool to understand art under a different set of lenses. It doesn’t treat AI art as an alien object that crash-landed on culture the day somebody typed “astronaut riding a horse” into a text box. It puts AI in a long history of artists ceding part of the creative process to algorithms.

That’s what Bauman himself said in 2023: “In a way it’s that classic Philip Galanter ‘artist ceding control to an autonomous system.’” Bauman believes AI art is generative, and that AI is an autonomous system with different degrees of autonomy.

The “code” invented by the Blombos cavemen, for instance, “directed” the movement of their hands, ceding some autonomy to the algorithm but retaining final creative control. When we give an AI video generator like Seedream 2.5 a few assets with a prompt, we cede most of the autonomy and creative control to the algorithm.

The timeline’s AI guide treats today’s image generators as the latest step in the history of AI systems, which kicks off in 1955 with the Dartmouth proposal, a paper in which John McCarthy and his peers formally coined the term artificial intelligence.

McCarthy’s ideas set in motion the events that led computer science to conceive the earliest artificial neural networks or algorithm-driven machines like Harold Cohen’s AARON, a computer program that autonomously controlled a plotter in 1973.

[Screenshot: Le Random]

The archive also charts the transition to emergent machine learning. It starts with the work of digital media artist and VFX software developer Karl Sims, who used genetic algorithms to evolve digital creatures in 1994.

Two decades later, we arrive at the generative AI boom of the mid-2010s, with the first generative adversarial networks (GANs). Today, the latest diffusion models are so perfect that they have destroyed our reality as we know it, creating an endless stream of slop, lies, and art.

[Screenshot: Le Random]

The tools have dramatically changed since that very first line drawing, but the foundational impulse—relinquishing creative control to an autonomous system—has arguably remained constant.

One timeline, many angles

The relaunched timeline’s UX offers many different exploration paths. You can move through the history chronologically or play an automated, animated tour. You can also travel by ideas (which shows an interactive ideas cloud), threads (the interweaving strands of all the movements in generative art history you can explore through time) or people (the same, but with people grouped by different arts and organized in time on a concentric rings map, like the age of a tree).

[Screenshot: Le Random]

The timeline also allows you to play with the real “algorithms” used at different points in history with a collection of 36 interactive and playable machines of generative art. Instead of merely reading about all those tools, you get to play with them.

[Screenshot: Le Random]

Or perhaps you can go full meta and explore the timeline using one of the simplest algorithms ever used to create art: Roll the dice. Go to the main page and scroll down until you see the button that says “roll a moment” under the head “Leave it to chance.”

Clicking there will send you to a random moment in history, a play on Johann Philipp Kirnberger’s Musikalisches Würfelspiel, an algorithm the composer invented to create music back in 1757, rolling dice to select precomposed measures to assemble his piece.

Colleges are cutting administrative jobs. Some critics say that’s a good thing 

1 month ago

It was in the quiet of the summer when a new president at Louisiana State University said the school would lay off 25 administrators, including several who were high in the campus hierarchy, and shift the savings to faculty hiring and research.

“Transformational change,” the president, Wade Rousse, called it. He was “streamlining operations and finding efficiencies so the university can focus on” its faculty.

The move got limited attention outside Baton Rouge. But similar layoffs have been happening at universities and colleges nationwide in what may be a little-noticed tipping point in U.S. higher education. 

A decades-long increase in the number of employees on campuses who don’t actually teach—disparaged by critics as “administrative bloat”—is starting to reverse, new data suggests. 

The number of noninstructional employees at U.S. universities and colleges—the many people on campuses who don’t actually teach—fell last year more than it has at any time in at least the last decade, according to the College and University Professional Association for Human Resources, or CUPA-HR. 

And while the newly reported CUPA-HR figures cover only through the end of 2025, universities and colleges have continued to lay off noninstructional employees since then.

Another source, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, now projects “limited employment growth” for postsecondary administrators, which it says will be slower than for other occupations.

There are several caveats to these clues. 

The CUPA-HR survey is limited to the roughly 1,000 public and nonprofit universities and colleges that agreed to participate, for instance. The association cautioned against generalizing across the large variety of higher education institutions; noted that past downturns in staffing often have been followed by increases; and said it might be too early to draw conclusions about trends. 

But it shouldn’t come as a surprise that universities are resorting to layoffs across their workforces as they try to lower spending in the face of domestic and international student enrollment declines and federal funding cuts, says Kevin McClure, professor of higher education and chair of the Department of Educational Leadership at the University of North Carolina Wilmington.

“Institutions are shrinking. Some are closing. Some simply have fewer students, so are having to contract,” McClure says. “Those types of situations are often where layoffs are experienced or reorganizations happen.”

Since it’s typically harder to eliminate faculty than staff because of tenure and student demand for particular majors, he says, the newest layoffs are most likely to affect “employees and staff who aren’t as protected.”

Among administrators laid off at Louisiana State were the chief financial officer; a vice president who handled discrimination complaints; and 16 writers, video producers, and photographers in the marketing and communications office.

The University of Utah has announced it will eliminate as many as 855 noninstructional positions over the next year. The University of Minnesota cut 230 noninstructional jobs through layoffs and attrition. The University of Maryland laid off 84 staffers, eliminated vacant jobs, and froze hiring. 

Private, nonprofit universities and colleges of all sizes also have been trimming their administrative ranks.

Johns Hopkins University laid off 110 workers and imposed a hiring freeze. The New School in New York City shed 68 noninstructional employees. At Baker University in Kansas, 21 staff positions were eliminated, 27 others were frozen, and the president and other administrators took pay cuts. Emerson College in Boston laid off 12 administrators.

Even Harvard University eliminated 165 noninstructional jobs, including the director of its writing center. 

In most of these cases, the numbers represent small fractions of the noninstructional workforce, which accounts for more than half of all employees on campuses.

But “it’s encouraging that there are any cuts at all,” says Peter Wood, president of the conservative National Association of Scholars, which has been critical of administrative bloat and of diversity, equity, and inclusion offices, many of which are among those now being stripped of staff. 

There have been decades of increases in the numbers of noninstructional employees, attracting criticism at the highest levels and on social media accounts devoted entirely to making fun of higher education’s middle managers.

“Colleges began to see themselves as providing this very broad suite of services, all of which were personnel-intensive,” Wood says—athletics, housing, dining, security, transportation, mental health counseling, disability support, antidiscrimination efforts, information technology, data collection, fundraising, sustainability.

Some of these functions were expanded as students showed up who were not prepared for college-level work and needed more help. Some were in response to real or perceived demands from consumers for amenities that required additional staff, or were driven by intensifying competition and the race to rise up the college rankings.

Institutions also contend that their ever-growing workforces were required to comply with government red tape, though that has proven not to be as big a factor as they’ve said.

The administrative workforce “just grew and grew”—often, Wood says, at the expense of academic functions. 

In the process, administrative bloat became “one of those rare issues that unites critics of higher education with faculty members,” says Robert Kelchen, head of the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, who has studied it.

A faculty committee convened at Yale University to consider why higher education has lost so much public trust cited administrative bloat as one of the reasons. It said that even determining how many administrators there were at Yale “proved remarkably difficult.”

That in itself was a finding, the committee said in its report, released in April. The university “should be able to answer a straightforward question: What share of its resources is devoted to its core academic functions, and what share is not?”

Universities and colleges have “layers of bloated administration” for which “students and taxpayers are forced to foot the bill,” U.S. Under Secretary of Education Nicholas Kent told a White House roundtable last year.

“Students, families, and taxpayers are being asked to pay more and more each year to support rising institutional and administrative expenditures that often have little to do with actual learning,” he said.

The number of noninstructional employees on campuses is hard to definitively connect with what students pay. Another analysis of federal data, by the American Council of Trustees and Alumni, or ACTA, however, shows that administrative costs per student at public universities have generally been falling since their last peak, which came just before the COVID-19 pandemic. That analysis covers the period through 2024, the most recent for which the figure is available. 

“This seems really like a very stark correction,” says Armand Alacbay, ACTA’s chief of staff and senior vice president of strategy. 

Gallup surveys find that fewer than 4 in 10 Americans have confidence in higher education, down from nearly 6 in 10 in 2015; cost edges out perceived political agendas as the top reason, Alacbay says, noting, “That’s what’s really animating this whole discussion of administrative bloat, is the price of the product reaching an unsustainable level.”

The number of full-time administrators per 100 students at the top 200 universities that award doctoral degrees increased 39% from 1993 to 2007—more than twice as much as the number of students or faculty—according to one widely cited 2010 report by the conservative Goldwater Institute.

Another study picked up the trail in 2012 and looked at 1,529 public and private four-year colleges and universities. It found that administrative staffing continued to grow faster than instructional staffing through at least 2018, even after colleges and universities responded to the 2008 recession by promising to cut costs, and during a period when enrollment was declining.

Universities say their nonfaculty staff include employees in such areas as fundraising and sustainability, meaning they presumably raise or save money. Many others are in student services or provide technology support. 

There are indications that some schools are cutting employees who provide those functions, too, potentially resulting in fewer support services for students.

The University of Southern California has laid off academic advisers. The University of California, Los Angeles, cut 27 information technology workers. Indiana University Bloomington laid off 13 IT staffers.

Higher education should be thoughtful about where it’s making cuts, says McClure, the University of North Carolina professor.

Criticism of administrators “paints things in broad brush strokes,” he says. “Let’s be specific. What positions are we actually talking about that we need or don’t need? We should have that conversation.”

Universities and colleges “are in a different era now,” McClure adds. “And it’s going to require a different kind of staffing.”

Contact writer Jon Marcus at 212-678-7556, jmarcus@hechingerreport.org or jpm.82 on Signal.

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Sign up for our Higher Education newsletter. 

Flock is facing a surveillance backlash. Meanwhile, its drone business is booming

1 month ago

For much of the last year, security cameras sold by the tech firm Flock Safety have been blacked out, painted over, even wrapped in trash bags. Roundly criticized for ushering in high-tech surveillance, the company’s automated license plate readers (ALPRs) have not only been broken, but banned by cities across the nation. 

However, at the same time the ALPR backlash has been brewing, a contributor to financial challenges for the company, Flock has seen a different part of its business literally take flight. 

The company’s line of drones has become a key part of its current revenue and sales pitch. Flock founder and CEO Garrett Langley told the All-In Podcast in September that drone tech is the company’s “fastest-growing business unit right now.”

Founded in 2017, Flock is valued at $8.4 billion. Langley said drone tech is set to account for nearly half of its future revenue. At one point, the company was in negotiations to supply drones to police in Chula Vista, California, the San Diego suburb that has been on the forefront of drone policing. 

While local law enforcement often praise the technology—the San Francisco police hold up the tech as a key aspect in a recent drop in the crime rate—the increasing deployments of drones are worrying civil rights advocates about the balance of privacy versus security.

“The public conversation hasn’t caught up to how much of a problem drones are at this point,” says Beryl Lipton, senior investigative researcher at the Electronic Freedom Foundation. “There are very high-resolution cameras that can see thousands of feet away and are designed to not be seen by the people on the street.”  

The Rapid Rise of Police Drones

Flock’s growing push to sell aerial surveillance systems comes just as law enforcement vastly expands the use of what’s called drone-as-first-responder (DFR) programs.

Today, roughly 2,000 police departments and public safety agencies use this technology, which sends drones out to answer 911 calls and either clear the call (determine no additional police presence is necessary), help scout out the scene before other personnel arrive, or provide real-time insight during emergencies and standoffs. 

The ease of use of the technology, combined with the larger workforce shortages in policing and an effort to avoid high-speed car chases, have been cited as reasons to invest in these eyes in the sky. 

Flock has roughly 175 DFR customers across the country, but the growth opportunities are huge. According to retired Chief Charles L. Werner, founder of the Droneresponders industry group, there are about 125 new Federal Aviation Administration approvals for DFR programs every month.

The increasing technological capacity for cops to utilize cameras and drones flips the typical police process, says Brian Cox, head of police accountability at the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office. As he explains, instead of probable cause setting off police oversight—“you’re free from government oversight absent some extraordinary reason”—the increasing ability of police to surveil first, to “collect all the data and figure out what the problem is,” raises important constitutional questions about privacy. 

Flock believes drones are an important tool for law enforcement, says Paris Lewbel, Flock public safety manager. Flock began expanding its drone offerings in 2024 when it acquired Aerodome.

The company has also prioritized the production of its new Alpha drone in the U.S., with plans to open a factory in Georgia by 2027. Building domestically allows the company to gain market share after the sale of Chinese drones such as DJI were banned by President Donald Trump in December 2025. Flock is also selling drone security to private companies and even prisons.

The firm’s technology—Alpha drones can travel at an industry-leading 60 mph and go 45 minutes between charges—gives Flock users more expansive abilities to track drivers and suspects, and to incorporate drone footage into its AI-powered analysis tools. 

Like many other police tech companies, such as Axon, Flock wants to create an ecosystem of technology, becoming the go-to-vendor for law enforcement (and locking them into their proprietary systems, says Lipton). 

“The technology really speaks for itself,” Lewbel tells Fast Company. “If you speak to law enforcement agencies that have started to deploy drones as a first responder, they’re seeing significant positive impact.”

A car with a license plate that appears on an ALPR hot list can activate rapid drone deployment. First, an ALPR camera clocks a license plate on a watch list and sends an alert; once the alert is triggered, a police officer needs to press a button to launch a drone, a safeguard designed to keep humans in the loop. Once airborne, the drone can track the vehicle.

Proponents point to safeguards that they argue limit the surveillance applications of this tech and focus it on active investigations or incidents. San Francisco District Attorney Brooke Jenkins claims the city’s fleet of nearly 100 drones gets used responsibly: only in the course of active investigations, and not as a blanket surveillance.

Lewbel says Flock drones can’t do ALPR scans automatically (though he does concede that an office looking at a drone camera could simply call in the license plate number). But others argue that not only can it do that, but it’s also trivial for an office to enter a plate number seen through a drone camera into an ALPR system. 

San Francisco as a battleground

One of the main battlegrounds of public opinion around drones and policing is San Francisco, where the wider push to incorporate an array of high-tech policing tools has become a much bigger political issue, as evidence of improper data sharing with other agencies became public.

Drones, including Flock models, in addition to hundreds of stationary license plate cameras, came to the SFPD after the city passed Proposition E in 2024, which allowed the city to use technology and centralized command stations called real-time crime centers.

Before, the city was “still playing old-school cops and robbers,” says Jenkins, the San Francisco DA. Now, she says, these tools have helped dramatically improve response times, are able to chase suspects, and are being used as evidence in courtrooms. 

The city is in the midst of rewriting its drone policies, with leaders finding themselves fiercely debating the efficacy and impact of this kind of policing. In early September, the San Francisco Police Commission was set to vote on the proposed drone policy, but the meeting was delayed until October 14.

Jenkins says a good part of the proposed reforms she supports would deal with reforming the way the system is used to prevent outside agency access, and to “function as a deterrent to those who might think of abusing it, and really build trust with the public that it’ll be used the right way.” 

Others find the city’s latest drone policy proposal lacking. Detractors argue the proposal’s broad language would justify increased drone surveillance deployment. Lipton calls it a “really atrociously inadequate drone policy.”

San Francisco law enforcement holds itself up as a case study for the use of technology. Jenkins says drones and other high-tech tools have helped lead to a decrease in crime, though research shows the recent improvement may have more varied and complicated contributors.

(There isn’t currently an independent, peer-reviewed study on the impact of this tech in San Francisco, though a preliminary study of more than 200 police departments that wasn’t peer reviewed suggested the tech does have an impact on crime rates.)

According to SFPD stats, from March 2024 to August 4, 2026, DFR responded to 4,000 incidents, and assisted in more than 1,550 cases and more than 655 arrests of suspects, meaning drone footage was utilized during the investigation.

So far in 2026, DFR has been used with 40 search warrants and has been involved in 70-plus chases. The use of the technology for policing varied: A drone unit helped track suspect cars, which led to an arrest and conviction for pickpockets operating in Chinatown. 

Drone footage has already been utilized in a number of court cases and prosecutions in San Francisco, though it can be tricky to fully track its use. In a case still in preliminary hearing, for example, drone evidence that helped track a defendant fleeing a scene did lead to a felony stop and arrest, but won’t be used in court, according to the DA’s office. 

Do Drones Challenge the Definition of Privacy?

Drone policing raises other significant questions, including legal issues, that opponents say remain unanswered. 

The recent San Francisco policy proposal would reduce evidence retention from 12 months to 30 days. Flock has set its default policy at retention for seven days. As Jenkins argues, “We don’t have the time, the staffing, nor the interest to collect data on law-abiding people. We just don’t, and so every ounce of access to this data is preserved for investigations of criminal activity. Period.”

But that preservation can be an issue, Cox and others note. Is the analysis drawn from that video—where cars went, what suspects met with other suspects, where people gathered—stored as data elsewhere, rendering the elimination of video a formality? 

Flock’s Lewbel says after a video is destroyed, there’s still flight information, due to the audit log of flights that gets added to online public transparency portals operated by public safety agencies. And these drone videos often get classified as evidence, which agencies upload to their own digital evidence management systems, which get retained for much longer periods of time.

Others raise the issue of warrantless surveillance. Police departments often utilize the argument that drone surveillance happens in public, where a cop could be observing someone’s behavior, and there’s no expectation of privacy. Tapping a phone, which requires observing what happens in someone’s home and carries the expectation of privacy, requires a judge’s discretion and decision. 

Jenkins makes the same argument in favor of police being able to utilize drones without a judge’s warrant. “You have a constitutional expectation of privacy when you talk on the phone,” she says. “Therefore, that is the reason that police and law enforcement have to go get a warrant before being allowed to violate that expectation of privacy. When you are in public, you do not. You don’t have the same entitlement, nor should you have the same expectation. The drone can only surveil what’s in public.”

She also argues you can see and hear the drones, making their presence obvious. 

But there’s no way existing constitutional understanding would permit the constant possibility of video surveillance, Cox argues, both as it pertains to the right to privacy and the freedom of association. Could you ever meet someone without fear, knowing that interaction could be logged and tracked?

He considers these issues open questions that need to be decided in a court of law; federal courts have already begun to grapple with the way the technology’s retrospective and search features may come in conflict with the Fourth Amendment’s guarantees around unlawful search and seizure. 

Jenkins argues that the introduction of drones for policing has been a new positive for the city, and has lived up to what the voters expected when they passed Proposition E. Technology, she says, has helped the department succeed, and taking it away or restricting it would be a mistake. 

“We can’t go back to that place out of fear,” she says. “You do what it takes to put guardrails in. You don’t throw out the baby with the bathwater because it’s dirty, right? That’s not how it works, and that’s not in the best interests of our communities.”

Detractors argue it just entrenches more tech that will always be ripe for potential abuses. “This is the exact sort of mission creep that I think we kind of anticipated was going to happen,” says Lipton.

They’re cheap, they’re kitschy, and investment bankers love them

1 month ago

When strolling the hallways of his first internship in investment banking, Alex R. kept noticing small trinkets crowding the desks of executives and junior analysts alike, as if each workstation grew its own skyline made up of knickknacks.

Some were simple: glass prisms the size of a coffee mug with a company’s name and the bank’s logo etched on the surface. But others were much flashier. Some were adorned with 3D-printed elements, floating features, and specialized lighting. The awards’ silhouettes sometimes took the form of the Bitcoin logo, a game console, or even a Japanese temple.

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition]

Alex, who is now a full-time investment banker in New York City, wondered what these eccentric objects were. He sheepishly broached the topic with an analyst on the team, not wanting to look uninitiated. “I asked them, ‘What are these things?’” he tells Fast Company. (Alex’s last name as well as those of other bankers mentioned have been redacted due to fear of professional repercussions.)

For an industry whose public image is one of intensity (see the ego-driven, viciously competitive characters in Industry or the Wolf of Wall Street), the idea of the grown men behind million-dollar deals swooning over tiny desktop trinkets seems absurd. Especially when flashier perks like steak dinners at Casa Cipriani, bottles of Dom Perignon, and sometimes even the occasional Rolex are considered normal industry rewards.

But for many, it is the $100-a-piece deal toy that they covet the most. Taking many shapes and sizes, the figurines serve as a sort of participation trophy for the closure of a transaction—a memento for those involved in a deal and the bank’s clients.

To anyone outside the finance universe, the concept of deal toys is foreign, but within the industry the toys often become one of the highest signifiers of success for young analysts. So much so, when two investment bankers in their mid-twenties overheard a conversation about deal toys, they lit up with joy—mixed with confusion over why “normies” knew, or cared about, their tradition at all. “How did you hear about this in the first place?” one asked. The other chimed in, “I forget people don’t know these exist.”

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition] The art of the deal toy 

Before deal toys existed, bankers had newspaper clippings to commemorate their work.

The deals appeared in the form of newspaper tombstone ads to adhere to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s requirement to publicly disclose big deals like initial public offerings. The brief ads, which ran in publications like The Wall Street Journal or the Financial Times, were basic in style, listing the underwriters for a deal and brief details on the transaction.

Eventually, though no one can say exactly when, the tombstone came off the page and moved to the desk. (The name tombstone has evolved to become a synonym for a deal toy.) At some point in the 1970s, bankers looked for a more permanent recognition outside of a tiny newspaper ad that could get thrown out. 

“They started simply taking a digital print, a card cut out with all the deal information on it, and they would embed it into . . . lucite—that way, it would stay embedded and last forever, and they would gift that to everyone that was involved in the deal,” says Erik Steudler, founder and president/CEO of Milestone Awards, a deal toy manufacturer with offices from New York and Nashville to Hong Kong and London.

Eventually, a cottage industry of toy manufacturers emerged. Entrepreneurs figured that, regardless of location, financiers want a physical form of recognition. They were right.

A handful of companies focusing solely on corporate awards—like deal toys—gained momentum, employing dozens of designers and sales people. The current landscape is made up mostly of alumni of those original businesses who have branched out on their own.

Over the decades the practice grew into a global tradition, with in-house design teams working alongside financial institutions to develop their own trinkets, which are now made mostly in China. 

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition]

There was a brief decline in deal toys after the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, which triggered more stringent regulation on bank spending. The industry has since rebounded with an even larger demand as financial institutions lead more lucrative transactions than ever. As the size of deals goes up, so does the deal toy market. The tech boom and consolidation trend is also helping. Think big name mergers like the Paramount-Warner Brothers deal or forthcoming billion-dollar IPOs from AI companies like OpenAI. Deal toys are now a $60 million industry.

Designs have become more ambitious, too, with manufacturers using emerging technologies like 3D printing to create bespoke toys. “I find with every year that passes, there’s more and more that becomes feasible and durable,” says Gregory Thomas, sales director at HV Recognition, one of the leading firms in the industry with offices in Europe, Asia, and the U.S. “If you’d have asked me 10 years ago the stuff that I was doing today, I’d would’ve said you’ve lost your mind.”

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition]

Thomas, who has spent decades in the deal toy business, has personal highlights including a basketball enclosed in an acrylic box and a Nike Air Jordan sneaker the size of a loaf of bread, both made using custom molds and printing methods.

Thomas launched his former company’s Asia operations, has worked in various markets, and has noticed how design preferences change across markets. While European clients might prefer subdued, minimalist designs, American analysts often opt for a “bigger the better” approach.

Today, the toys take many shapes. When she was a sophomore intern, Kirsten W., a young investment banker in NYC, caught a couple of analysts swinging what looked like a baseball bat. It was actually a deal toy. “One of my VPs just got a new one and it’s a giant wizard on a marble plaque, and I’ve also seen a bowling ball,” she says.

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition] Making the deal toys

The life of a deal toy begins in the hands of junior analysts, who, upon closing a deal, are tasked with reaching out to manufacturers to develop a concept. While some view the process as just another checklist to complete, many use the opportunity as a creative outlet in an otherwise logistical job.

“The whole process is pretty exciting the first time you get to do it,” says Michael D., another young New York banker. “When you finally get it, it’s fun to see it in person, and people in the office are interested in seeing it as well.”

Sometimes analysts come in with a clear idea, referencing icons relevant to the deal. A transaction with a Japanese company might incorporate the country’s architecture, while other times a client’s special interest makes it onto the design—like the time a figure of Slash, the Guns N’ Roses guitarist, ended up on a deal toy.

Some manufacturers will take the initiative and seek out notable deals, as did Thomas, who reached out to industry contacts to propose a design for SpaceX’s $86 billion IPO.

Their proposal featured an alien dressed as a cowboy riding a vertical SpaceX rocket with LED lighting throughout; Elon Musk’s face was emblazoned in a crystal panel beside the deal’s details.

The timeline from brainstorming to unboxing the toys may run upwards of two or three months, depending on the complexity of the design. A more affordable toy might borrow from the original deal toys, set as clear prisms or glass cubes with the deal’s details printed on the object. But some toys can go as wild as physics will allow, with custom molds made for the objects, 3D printed elements, and even magnets used to create a floating illusion.

The budget for deal toys varies, with some deals having a budget of thousands of dollars. The budget determines who gets a toy. Larger budgets allow for dozens of team members to get one, sometimes even including the lawyers on the deal, while other times only a handful of analysts might make the cut.

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition] Bragging rights

While it may seem like frivolous spending, the toys have intangible value for both the bank and the bankers.

“We refer to it as ‘desktop advertisement,’” says Steudler at Milestone Awards. “The clients keep them on their desk . . . and will always remember the job that their investment bank did because their logos are on the deal toy and so they’ll go back to them.”

For the bankers, the toys are both a rite of passage and a token of appreciation for the hours of work that go into a transaction.

[Photo: Courtesy HV Recognition]

“You put so much time and effort into something and it’s a nice symbol of your work,” Kirsten says. “I think for more senior bankers it’s more of a sign of prestige—a ‘who has more’ contest—but early on in your career I think it just more of a satisfying close, and nice to be recognized for your hard work.”

But the toys undoubtedly also feed into a character trait many associate with the finance industry.

“It’s a huge ego thing for bankers,” says Thomas at HV Recognition. “It’s almost like a portable CV.”

And while many acknowledge that the toys don’t really matter in the grand scope of things—they also agree, they kind of do.

“My personal opinion is that they don’t matter,” Michael says. But, he adds, “when my coworker makes fun of me for my football team losing, I remind him I have more deal toys.”

Meta’s Muse AI agent is a clever little bastard

1 month ago

He looks like a CoComelon character who grew up and mated with an E. coli microbe.

But don’t let looks fool you. Under the hood, Meta’s new Muse agentic AI platform is incredibly powerful—and potentially incredibly risky.

I’ve been testing Muse since Meta launched him on September 8. He’s a clever little bastard, provided you’re willing to tell him basically everything about your life.

Late to the party

For years, Meta has seemed inexcusably late to the AI party. While flashy startups like OpenAI and Anthropic were winning trillion-dollar valuations, Nvidia was getting fat on its success as a shovel-seller, and Google was slowly replacing its core product with AI, Meta seemed stuck in the past.

The company encouraged AI slop on its platforms, only to change its tune. It did legitimate research in open-weight models, but also took some hilariously wrong-headed steps, like releasing AI chatbots that mimic celebrities without their permission.

It was tempting to write Meta off as an also-ran. Perhaps Mark Zuckerberg was still gun-shy from the abject failure of the Metaverse, and was going to sit this particular revolution out.

Then, Muse landed.

Almost overnight, the platform was stealing market share from Meta’s competitors, and growing shockingly fast. Less than a month post-launch, Muse had wracked up 6.6 million downloads, and an even-more-impressive 1.8 million daily active users. Citi thinks it could generate $27 billion in revenue in fairly short order.

Meta, in other words, was late to the party—but now that it’s arrived, the company’s tech is all anyone can talk about.

Distressingly fluffy

As with many things Mark Zuckerberg creates, Muse is weird.

The agentic AI platform is personified by a distressingly fluffy and cute little smiling mascot, who adorns every Muse billboard and types away cheerfully at the top of the Muse app when you chat with it.

Experts have long warned against personifying AI. “Phooey!” said Zuckerberg. 

Muse is as anthropomorphized as platforms come. Users can customize their Muse avatar to their own preferences and give their specific Muse a name. (“Mark Zuckerberg” is apparently not allowed.)

When the bot chats with users, it does so in a friendly, personal manner. There are lots of first-person pronouns and text-message conventions. Ask Muse a question, and it will “thumbs-up” your chat while it slowly types out a response, just like your boomer uncle.

Chatting with ChatGPT feels a bit like schmoozing with your accountant, or perhaps your proctologist. Where ChatGPT is overly formal and stodgy, Muse’s language is zippy, confident, and a little cheeky. Behind that fluffy, personable facade, though, is a wholly different kind of AI.

Most chatbots today act essentially like glorified search engines. You type in a query, the bot does some research, and you get a response back that’s mainly informational.

Muse, in contrast, is an agentic AI platform. Rather than just providing information, it’s designed to take specific actions on behalf of its users—writing emails, booking travel, filling out forms, and signing into websites.

Meta pitches Muse as “AI that gets it done” and suggests handing it tasks like booking a flight or registering for a 10K race.

To work this specific kind of magic, Muse makes use of virtual machines. Every user essentially gets a virtual computer in the cloud, which their Muse can use to carry out its duties. This lets the bot do things that others struggle with, like browsing complex websites on your behalf, signing into your accounts, drafting and sending emails via your internet service provider of choice, and more.

It’s an approach pioneered by OpenClaw, a techie-friendly agentic AI platform. Using a virtual machine lets Muse do anything a human might do on a computer, without the risk of wrecking your actual computer when things inevitably go wrong.

Tell me everything!

That combination—a friendly and conversational demeanor, an agentic AI empowered to take specific actions, and a virtual computer that lets Muse actually act on its ideas—is a compelling one.

If you’ve ever shouted at ChatGPT, “Just do it for me!,” when it gives you complex instructions for disputing a parking ticket or making a doctor’s appointment and then bows out, you’ll love Muse’s can-do attitude.

I asked what car I should lease, and Muse got me quotes for a Kia. When I asked how I could save money, it scanned through my financial data, determined Hulu was ripping me off, found better plans tailored to my family’s actual usage, and offered to switch me to one. Its advice saved me $80 per month.

Muse’s virtual computer also allows it to work when you’re not actively chatting with it. Periodically, I’ll get a notification from Muse, telling me it’s prepared a report on how I can decrease my electric bill, or sell my old Tesla for top dollar.

All this power, though, comes with a price.

Most chatbots are squeamish about asking users for personal data, or access to their most intimate, sensitive accounts.

Not Muse.

The second you open the app, Muse asks for full access to your Gmail, as well as permission to read your text messages and browse the photos on your phone.

The app also wants to know your location at all times (via your phone’s GPS), and encourages you to share conversations you’ve had with other competing chatbots so it can “get to know you” better.

Muse also presumably has access to the copious amounts of data Meta has gathered about you through decades of low-key surveillance. 

I once ran an experiment to see what data Meta was capturing about me. I found that the company was spying on nearly every website I visited, and was even tracking things like when I put a specific smoothie into my Doordash cart, even if I didn’t buy it.

Now, Muse likely has access to all that data, as well as any live accounts and data I might choose to voluntarily hand it.

Again, all that information makes it uniquely clever. But using Muse also means handing complete control of your data to a friendly little dude who happens to be owned by a demonstrably less friendly one.

Tread Carefully

Is Meta’s voracious appetite for personal data a reason to avoid Muse? Does the app’s friendly little face conceal a monster lurking below? Not necessarily.

Agentic AI is powerful, and it’s here to stay. 

Muse is the first real attempt to put the technology in the hands of everyday people. But AI agents are already making huge impacts in the business world. 

And now that Muse has proved the concept, Meta’s competitors are tripping over themselves to release personal agentic AI platforms of their own. OpenAI’s version features a mascot that looks like a mash-up of Clippy and the poop emoji.

Eschewing agentic bots like Muse, then, would ultimately be about as effective as ignoring ChatGPT in 2023. The tech is here. And besides, even if you avoid apps like Muse, they’ll likely slurp up your personal data via your friends and family members.

Still, personal agentic AI is a brand-new, largely untested technology. There are already reports of strangers appearing on users’ doorsteps, summoned by Muse for Facebook Marketplace transactions that no one authorized.

So it’s reasonable to proceed carefully. Personally, I’ve handed Muse select bits of data directly, but I haven’t allowed it to access my calendar or Gmail.

Amid all the furor over agentic AI, it’s important to remember that you don’t need to turn your entire life over to a gigantic tech company, even if a fluffy little bot asks you very nicely.

Will the chief AI officer role survive?

1 month ago

Chief AI officer may be one of the most important executive hires companies make in this decade. It may also be one of the shortest-lived.

Just a few years ago, most boards probably would’ve questioned whether they needed a dedicated leader for artificial intelligence. But when ChatGPT started to dominate public consciousness in late 2022 and early 2023, the conversation changed. The rush began to launch AI practices, assemble AI task forces and committees, and of course, appoint chief AI officers.

The rationale for hiring a chief AI officer was and remains sound. Without a dedicated person owning AI strategy, initiatives can fragment across teams or lack clear connection to talent, risk, and business opportunity. And given how quickly I’ve seen the role gain traction in my work advising companies on technology leadership, I’m not surprised that a recent IBM study found more than three-quarters of organizations have a chief AI officer.

But as AI becomes an enterprise-wide capability, the logic of a single owner is harder to sustain. If AI is part of every role, workflow, and major decision, why is only one executive in charge?

That’s where the paradox lies: The better a chief AI officer does their job today, the less their organization may need the role in the future.

There’s precedent for this kind of executive lifecycle. Think about the trajectory of the chief digital officer (CDO), which grew from a niche position at just 6% of companies in 2014 to 21% of companies in 2018; the pace of hiring appeared to peak in 2016.

In that era, companies needed a point person to design and implement digital strategy. But as CDOs helped transform their organization, “digital” transitioned from a specialized capability to something integrated across every domain. And in some cases, CDOs who weren’t integrated with the core business or overlapped with other C-suite roles struggled to maintain relevance.

AI adoption will likely mirror that trajectory because it is another operating model change. In theory, AI should fundamentally reshape how work happens, from how finance operates to how HR recruits talent to how CEOs make decisions. The desired endpoint is AI as an underlying infrastructure.

This means that if a chief AI officer does their job correctly, they’ll eventually make their standalone role unnecessary. They’ll act not only as a technologist but a transformation expert who helps manage change, establish governance, and drive business value. Critically, they’ll also build AI fluency across the C-suite until AI becomes everyone’s responsibility.

However, obsolescence doesn’t need to be the endpoint for the chief AI officer. Instead, I see potential for these leaders to work themselves out of their role and into a different one through a three-stage evolution.

In the first phase, the chief AI officer is an evangelist. Their primary goal is to convince the organization that AI matters, building awareness of the technology and encouraging experimentation to support adoption. In 2026, most organizations have already moved past this phase.

The second phase is where most organizations are now: the shift from experimentation to accountability. The chief AI officer evolves into an operator, with the mission of driving value and demonstrating ROI for boards and investors.

The third phase is where the chief AI officer lays the groundwork for their next act. Over the next few years, they will become architects, building systems that enable other executives to take ownership of AI within their functions. They help distribute AI accountability, so the CFO owns AI-enabled finance, the CHRO owns AI-enabled talent, the COO owns AI-enabled operations, and so on.

In my work, I’m already seeing signs of this shift. AI competency is increasingly appearing in job descriptions across all C-suite roles. Executives are expected to be AI enabled themselves, and also enable their teams to use the technology effectively. At the same time, companies are embedding AI champions within each business unit to identify potential uses and govern adoption, rather than relying on a centralized AI “command center.”

A chief AI officer who successfully orchestrates this transition will reduce the need for a separate AI department and, in turn, their role. But they’ll also gain a unique understanding of the enterprise, spanning across technology, operations, talent, governance, strategy, and organizational change. That experience positions them to become a broader transformation leader, or even a strategic advisor to the CEO and board.

Right now, the vast majority of organizations still need a designated leader to prove where AI creates value and help embed AI as a capability within every executive role. But over the next five years, companies are more likely to eliminate standalone AI teams than create them.

Long term, chief AI officers will help their organizations win by embedding AI so thoroughly that it becomes nearly invisible. In doing so, they can prove their readiness for broader enterprise leadership. My bet is that some of the most successful chief AI officers will eventually move into COO, transformation, or even CEO succession pipelines.

While the specific role of chief AI officer may eventually disappear, the presence of these leaders doesn’t have to. Organizations that are intentional about recognizing and developing their potential can turn a transitional role into a training ground for future enterprise leadership.

A super PAC trying to influence the Maine Senate election seems to have advertised to the wrong Portland

1 month ago

In most cases, confusing Portland, Maine, with Portland, Oregon, might be seen as an innocent faux pas. But in the case of political actors ahead of an election, it can be a costly—and frankly comedic—blunder.

A recent attack ad targeting Troy Jackson—the Democratic candidate in the Maine Senate race who is running against incumbent Republican Sen. Susan Collins—has appeared in front of users far from Maine, leading many to believe its placement was a mistake.

Funded by the Defending Main Street super PAC, the 30-second ad titled “Too Many Taxes” focuses on taxes and the cost-of-living crisis, which both Collins and Jackson have made central to their campaigns in the lead-up to the election in November.

But despite the ad reportedly costing Defending Main Street around $25,000, the message might not be effective. Shown for the first time on October 8, it has racked up over 1.2 million views—but to viewers in Oregon, not Maine.

“I’ve gotten 5 anti-Troy Jackson ads in the last 24 hours. I choose to believe they mixed up Portlands,” one user, whose location is set to Oregon, said on X.

Many others with an Oregon location chimed in to share their similar experiences, with one saying: “I’ve gotten them too. lol.” Another added: “I’ve gotten so many this week.”

Some social media users shared screenshots of the ad’s Google Ads Transparency Center page—a public repository of ads served on Google—which showed the selected region for the ads as zip codes from Oregon.

The Google Ads page has since been updated with Maine zip codes.

The Intercept reported on the mix-up earlier.

“So out of touch”

The apparent error is not the first Republican mix-up this election cycle. In September, Sen. Eric Schmitt of Missouri tried to catch former special counsel Jack Smith in a gotcha moment during a Senate hearing—only to confuse two basketball teams (the Hawks and Hawkeyes), collapsing his line of questioning and sparking widespread mockery online.

While Collins’s campaign and Defending Main Street have yet to speak out on the mishap—or respond to a request for comment—Jackson’s campaign has already noticed the situation.

“Susan Collins’ allies are so out of touch with Maine, they can’t even find it on a map,” Dan Gottlieb, spokesperson for Jackson’s campaign, tells Fast Company. “Good luck convincing Mainers you know what’s best for them when you don’t know which Portland they live in.”

As a domestic car sales slump continues, China’s automakers lean on exports

1 month ago

China’s passenger car exports surged 64% in September from the same month in 2025, an industry association reported Monday, as Chinese automakers increasingly focus on exports to drive growth amid sluggish domestic sales.

China exported around 919,000 passenger vehicles in September, lifted by overseas demand for plug-in hybrids and pure electric vehicles, data from the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers showed. In the first nine months of 2026, China exported over 7.1 million passenger cars, up more than 70% from the same period last year.

Meanwhile, domestic passenger car sales in China fell for most of the year as automakers faced weaker consumer confidence at home and scaled-back government subsidies. They fell 27% year over year in September to over 1.6 million units, according to the association.

China is the world’s largest vehicle exporter, but is facing increasing skepticism from trade partners who fear it’s undermining their domestic industries and trade balance.

The European Union is capping Chinese hybrid vehicle imports at 350,000 a year, officials say.

Chinese car sales grow in regions including Europe

In recent months, Chinese automakers have more aggressively targeted rapid growth in overseas markets such as Europe, Latin America, Southeast Asia, and Africa. Canada is also opening its doors to Chinese EV exports under a tariff cut deal with China.

The industry increasingly relies on overseas markets for sales and profit growth as players seek to offset weakness in the domestic market, analyst Stephen Chan of S&P Global Ratings said.

Consultancy AlixPartners and some auto analysts expect Chinese automakers to export nearly or around 10 million vehicles globally in 2026.

In Europe, Chinese automakers are increasingly challenging the European auto industry with lower costs and prices. AlixPartners’ analysis found, for example, that a Chinese-branded EV costs around $20,000 to produce, compared with $31,000 for a European equivalent.

EU to cap Chinese hybrid vehicle imports at 350,000 annually

The EU has already imposed higher tariffs on pure electric vehicles from China, prompting Chinese carmakers to export more hybrid vehicles. Recent policy discussions have focused on the rapid rise in sales of Chinese hybrids in Europe.

Chinese automakers captured around 12% of Europe’s new-car market in August and accounted for one in four hybrid sales in the region, said a research note by Deutsche Bank.

Amid growing pressure on the EU to rebalance trade with China, EU trade chief Maroš Šefčovič said Friday that the two sides had reached an interim deal that could halve Chinese hybrid vehicle exports to the bloc.

The agreement sets an annual import quota of 350,000 hybrid vehicles made in China, including plug-in hybrids, two senior EU officials said Monday. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity under European Commission policy.

Starting as early as December, customs authorities across the 27-nation bloc will coordinate monitoring of these imports and halt further shipments once the annual quota is reached, one official said. The limit excludes cars made in Europe by Chinese companies.

Analysts said protectionist measures would likely continue to cloud Chinese automakers’ overseas outlook.

An import cap on Chinese hybrid cars would likely disrupt the highly profitable vehicle export growth that Chinese automakers recently enjoyed in the European market, Deutsche Bank analysts said.

“You can’t expect BYD or the other OEMs [original equipment manufacturers] to export too many cars without facing tariffs or pushbacks from the foreign governments,” Xiao Feng, head of Hong Kong and China industrials research at investment group CITIC CLSA, told reporters recently.

Geopolitics is the biggest challenge to BYD’s overseas expansion, executive vice president Stella Li, who leads the Chinese EV giant’s global growth, acknowledged at an event this month.

BYD has therefore been expanding overseas production, including setting up plants in Thailand, Indonesia, Brazil, and Hungary, she told the Milken Institute Asia Summit in Singapore.

More overseas production limits impact from trade curbs

Chinese automakers will likely continue to expand overseas production to reduce exposure to tariffs and other risks, said Ming Lee, head of Greater China automotive and industrial research at BofA Global Research, a unit of Bank of America.

“More and more volume will be made locally,” he said.

Meanwhile, the U.S. has effectively shut Chinese EVs out of its market with hefty tariffs. President Donald Trump’s meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping during Xi’s state visit to Washington last month yielded no deal on access for Chinese EVs.

Experts say continued political uncertainty likely makes the U.S. market a lower priority for Chinese automakers.

—By Chan Ho-Him and Sam McNeil, Associated Press

Checked
11 minutes 22 seconds ago
Fast Company
Fast Company inspires a new breed of innovative and creative thought leaders who are actively inventing the future of business.
Subscribe to Fast Company feed