Ryan DiLazio was a rock star at his job. On paper.
It was 2022, and DiLazio was a manager of social marketing and strategy at a global advertising agency, where he was working with such brands as Sour Patch Kids, Chicken in a Biskit, and Nutter Butter, all subsidiaries of the food giant Mondelēz International. Technically, DiLazio’s role only encompassed ideating social media concepts and scheduling them, but he was regularly taking on more creative work, too—including designing Instagram posts and recording TikToks.
Soon, DiLazio’s creative work was taking off: His wacky, deep-fried TikTok strategy for Nutter Butter was regularly generating millions of views, while an activation based on the hit show The Summer I Turned Pretty was garnering major praise from higher-ups. “The president of Mondelēz is on an email thread going, ‘This is the best work I have ever seen from our brands in years,’” DiLazio recalls.
Behind the scenes, though, DiLazio received a different message. “I got put on a PIP,” he says, using the HR acronym for “performance improvement plan,” the first step on the road to potentially being fired.
For DiLazio, who’s built a personal brand around identifying and playing off of the weirdest trends on social media, it was a moment of whiplash. He’d been hired for his personal brand, only for it to be called into question.
“I can no longer count the number of times I’ve been both hired and punished by agencies for having the ‘fresh perspective’ they’re looking for and my ‘fingers on the pulse of culture,’” he says. “I have been plucked from the internet for my tone of voice, for noticing things others don’t, and for a willingness to try new things. Each factor can so easily become a double-edged sword.”
I interviewed DiLazio for a special report on how people are building their personal brands in 2026, featuring more than 200 insights (you can read that here).
{"blockType":"mv-promo-block","data":{"imageDesktopUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2026\/09\/BCY-TopArt-Article1-1.gif","imageMobileUrl":"https:\/\/images.fastcompany.com\/image\/upload\/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit\/wp-cms-2\/2026\/09\/BCY-bug-2026-square.jpg","eyebrow":"","headline":"\u003Ca href=\u0022https:\/\/www.fastcompany.com\/91582246\/personal-brand-special-report-207-insights-ideas-grow-brand-career\u0022\u003EPersonal Brand Special Report: 207 insights and ideas to grow your brand and career\u003C\/a\u003E","dek":"","subhed":"","description":"","ctaText":"Read More","ctaUrl":"https:\/\/www.fastcompany.com\/91582246\/personal-brand-special-report-207-insights-ideas-grow-brand-career?utm_source=fcwebsite\u0026utm_medium=promo_block\u0026utm_campaign=91611379","theme":{"bg":"#2b2d30","text":"#ffffff","eyebrow":"#9aa2aa","subhed":"#ffffff","buttonBg":"#3b3f46","buttonHoverBg":"#3b3f46","buttonText":"#ffffff"},"imageDesktopId":91604489,"imageMobileId":91604719,"shareable":false,"slug":"","wpCssClasses":""}}
When we spoke, DiLazio had moved on to become a partner at his own creative agency, Loudmouth, and managing editor of the digital culture newsletter and creative advocacy agency Silence, Brand! Although his quirks may have been a double-edged sword in a corporate environment, they’re now a key marketing tool for his own businesses.
Still, DiLazio’s experience epitomizes the often unspoken reality for those developing personal brands: While almost everyone I spoke with believes that building their personal brand has resulted in major career gains, the majority also told me they’ve experienced some meaningful challenges along the way.
Personal branding can be a divisive topic, and critics often focus only on the negatives. Conversely, evangelists tend to ignore the inevitable setbacks in the process. Our take—grounded in the reality that you have a personal brand and are being judged by it no matter what—offers a frank look at the obstacles and how to overcome them.
In this dispatch from the world of personal branding, you’ll learn:
- The biggest problems people encounter as their personal brand takes shape
- What they do to evolve their brands
- How to balance a personal brand with a full-time job
- When and where to draw boundaries to protect yourself
- Where systems and structures can be transformative, including one leader’s vibe-coded “Personal Brand Command Centre”
- Why women and underrepresented groups face greater scrutiny in their brand building—and what they do to take back power
The pigeonhole: When your personal brand becomes a reputational limitation
“I was taught to be creative, to ask questions that make people think, to push forward into uncharted territory, but the reality is all of these things make some uncomfortable. Some are even threatened by any or all of those things in combination. Where I may see a wide-open opportunity, some see a threat to their title, internal agency politics, or a dynamic I will never be involved in.
“I’ve seen this manifest as meetings I wasn’t invited to, chats about me that I hear about later . . . odd questions [asked] of me such as ‘Are you sure you’re a strategist . . . not a creative?’ and more. (I’m BOTH!)” —Ryan DiLazio, partner, Loudmouth; senior managing editor, Silence, Brand!
DiLazio’s hard-earned advice: “Turn your spite and frustration into more creativity. Nobody can tell the ending of a story you haven’t finished writing, especially your creative career. Your employer doesn’t own your creativity the way they’d like to. Give it somewhere to live outside of work: Post a daily photo to a Tumblr. Start a blog. Build a hobby project. Freelance on the side. And if it comes to it, quit the toxic job. Never let someone else’s lack of confidence become the roadblock to your creativity.”
“When you are seen on social media as a personal brand, they don’t necessarily expect you to execute, too. Some treat you like a talking head instead of an operator. They expect you to want to be a brand evangelist instead of doing other work within the brand.” —Christina Garnett, chief customer and communications officer (fractional), Neuemotion
Garnett’s hard-earned advice: “Most of what people see from me online is the thinking. The execution happens in rooms they’ll never see. So I started posting about that side, too: what we built, what broke, what the numbers did. Once people see you shipping, they stop assuming the posts are the job.
“If you have a visible profile, people will fill in your job description for you. I’ve learned to define what I own at the start of any role or engagement, in writing, before anyone else does. When requests to be the face of something come in later, there’s already a document that says what I was brought in to deliver.”
“In the first three years transitioning back from a paid employee to a brand that has its own product out in the marketplace, what I didn’t want to do is be seen as a consultant. I knew that there are only so many consultants who are going to succeed, especially within one segment. Go look at any McKinsey PowerPoint presentation, BCG PowerPoint presentation, or any consultancy presentation: They all look the fuck the same. They use the same bullet points, the same color backgrounds. You have to break those digital lock-ins. You have to break the rules. You can’t stand out if you’re fitting in.” —Evan Shapiro, chaos cartographer, ESHAP
Shapiro’s hard-earned advice: “As an independent agent in the business world, a superpower combined with passion can be reframed as ‘compelling expertise.’ And that kind of expertise can be valued in the marketplace.
“Twenty-five years ago, at the urging of a great coach, I set out to find and define my superpower. I studied the things I did well—and the things I did not. I asked others to tell me what they thought my unique talent is. I looked for patterns until they emerged. The answer: Lead change. It’s simple. It’s broad. And yet it’s also unique. It’s flexible enough as not to be limiting, but specific enough to own.
“I love storytelling. I don’t write to make money. I don’t put out my content with an expectation of return. I ship my stuff because I’m compelled to—because I love it and I desperately want to help things and people change for the better. So leading change through storytelling became my brand.”
“I attached myself to a market that has basically collapsed in the last year. Now every time someone searches for me, it’s all VR, and that limits the type of roles I can pivot to.” —Anonymous VR developer who has worked with Fortune 500 companies
VR developer’s hard-earned advice: “Basically, I have a ton of prestige names and shiny awards, and I haven’t really been properly paid in a year. It sucks! It was a huge mistake, and I would caution people against going down this road and just build a regular Degular linear résumé instead.”
“‘Riches are in the niches’ can be true, but a niche can also pigeonhole you and close off adjacent opportunities. That happened to me with GearJunkie [a syndicated newspaper column of outdoor gear reviews]. Some advertisers saw my brand as too hardcore for their campaign or product launch. Despite my newspaper roots and dozens of stories for The New York Times, I sometimes felt the GearJunkie identity positioned me more as a sponsored athlete or brand ambassador than a journalist.” —Stephen Regenold, founder, Regenold.co; founder and former editor of the media brand GearJunkie
Renegold’s hard-earned advice: “If you feel typecast, be explicit about how your brand is evolving. Put a stake in the ground: Explain the subjects, audiences, or geographies you’re expanding into, and back that up with your work.”
My personal brand is a time suck. What now?
“It’s a lot to maintain a personal brand. I also feel like I don’t have a choice.” —Chanele McFarlane, senior communications adviser, Lakeridge Health
McFarlane’s hard-earned advice: “I squeeze my personal brand work into the small pockets of time I do have, whether that’s while waiting at my kids’ swimming lessons, after bedtime, during lunchtime, or waking up early on a weekend morning. This allows me to spend roughly 6 to 10 hours a week building my personal brand by researching, writing content, networking, applying to opportunities, and prepping for speaking engagements. It has created incredible opportunities throughout my career . . . but I have to be honest that it’s also a significant commitment, especially at this stage of my life. One of the best changes I’ve made recently is focusing on building systems that make personal branding more sustainable.
“Earlier this year, I actually vibe-coded something I call my ‘Personal Brand Command Centre,’ a centralized dashboard that helps me manage my content ideas, research, publishing pipeline, and opportunities. I’ve also started incorporating AI and automations to support the work behind the scenes. For example, I use scheduled tasks to stay informed about trends relevant to my expertise, identify potential content ideas, and discover visibility opportunities I may not find otherwise. I jotted down my initial ideas for my dashboard while on my train ride home from work and created version one while curled up on the couch in that small window of time I have after getting my kids to bed.”
“There is pressure to remain visible and consistent, even when you do not feel particularly interesting or have anything meaningful to say.” —James Farnfield, founder and CEO, Shake Content
Farnfield’s hard-earned advice: “For me, it helps to treat content as documentation rather than invention. I’ll pull ideas from conversations I’ve had, things happening inside the business, mistakes we’ve made, questions clients keep asking, or something I’ve recently changed my opinion on. That removes a lot of the pressure to sit down and ‘come up with content.’”
“Creating content consistently requires a significant investment of time and energy. It also doesn’t always come naturally to me. For example, sitting in front of a camera and recording videos isn’t something I particularly enjoy, so I’ve learned to lean into formats that feel more authentic, like writing.” —Aarati Cohly, founder and principal consultant, Cohly Consulting
Cohly’s hard-earned advice: “One approach I’ve been experimenting with is sitting down for a few hours at a time to think through the overall story or narrative I want to tell, the different content pillars I want to hit, and then developing content in bulk that I can share throughout the month, rather than treating every post as a one-off.
“Rather than treating personal branding as an entirely separate workstream, I’ve found it helpful to think about how it can integrate into my existing activities and actually strengthen other parts of my business. For example, I love doing event recaps. I’ve always been the person taking rigorous notes at events because I want to capture the key takeaways. Turning those notes into a post is a natural extension of something I would be doing anyway.”
“Maintaining a personal brand online requires time, effort, and energy. Although I love and enjoy it, posting every other day does feel like a job when I’m busy with school, too.” —Zinia Lee, fashion student/influencer, Fashion Institute of Technology
Lee’s hard-earned advice: “The key to completing a seemingly impossible array of tasks is to avoid anxiety and indecision by planning and organizing strategically. I use Notion and Notion Calendar to write down every little task, big or small, so that my mind doesn’t become overwhelmed. Each aspect of my life is categorized and sorted by urgency. For example, my content creation page in my Notion has ‘Edit, Post, Film, Collabs, Upcoming, Back Burner, and General’ tabs with more than 100 video ideas that would have escaped my brain without jotting them down.”
The uneven playing field: Navigating bias while building a brand
“For women especially, there’s this expectation that you will be showing your face more, that you will always be camera-ready, that you will also be running the team 100% of the time and participate in all of these extraneous things.” —Melanie Masarin, founder, Ghia
Masarin’s hard-earned advice: “Visibility is a tool, not a job description. Nobody is going to tell you how much of your face the business needs, so you have to decide that yourself, and then protect the time you need to actually run the company. Decide early what you actually want to be known for, and let that be the filter. From that point, it gets much easier to say no!”
“My perception was that I, as a woman, experienced more scrutiny in my professional life than did some of my male counterparts who might have also gone on the same or similar stages, but did not receive the same kind of scrutiny for their public activity.
“I was reported to HR for speaking up online about the devastating humanitarian crisis in Gaza. That was back in 2023. The complaint against me was that my advocacy might ‘scare off’ a potential CMO interested in doing business with the company, if they saw my ‘political’ posts . . . even though I made a conscious effort to focus my message on peace, human dignity, and human rights—values that shouldn’t be controversial.
“When I was first called into a meeting to discuss it, I was informed by my manager that the colleague who reported me to HR had suggested that I should only be allowed to post after 5 p.m. on LinkedIn. The reasoning given was that my public persona and my public presence might interfere with business. To be clear, that idea was never entertained and I was fully protected by my employer at that time. But I think what it suggests is an unequal relationship, where the employee might feel that they have public influence outside of their organization, but at the end of the day, your employment is dependent on whether your employer is satisfied with your online presence and whether you start being seen as a reputational threat.” —Anastasia Kārkliņa Gabriel, author, Cultural Intelligence for Marketers
Gabriel’s hard-earned advice: “Ground yourself in your own reality. When you feel unfairly scrutinized, it’s easy to allow others’ perceptions to dictate how you begin to see yourself. Before you realize it, you filter your words, question your own abilities, and, over time, make yourself smaller. But it’s your power that makes you ‘threatening,’ your talent that makes you ‘intimidating,’ and your vision that makes you ‘disruptive’—at least to them. Take it as a compliment. Use it. Let their doubt be your biggest fuel. Don’t let someone else’s discomfort become your new insecurity. Find your people so they can remind you—often—who you are and what you’re about. Never shrink yourself to fit someone else’s image of you.
“Also, document everything. Know that not everyone who appears to have your best interest at heart in the workplace necessarily does. Choose your ‘allies’ wisely: Remember that no leader who genuinely has your best interest at heart would ever expect you to play small to ‘earn’ their support or approval.”
“VC is an industry obsessed with being taken seriously. When I started making videos, there was a palpable belief that short-form content was inherently unserious. But I was already managing a $100 million fund and making high-conviction investments. I didn’t need video to make me serious. I needed it to help the right founders discover me.
“There is an additional caveat for women: Visibility creates opportunity, but it also creates more surface area for judgment. Women are still expected to demonstrate expertise without appearing too promotional. I decided I cared more about whether exceptional founders connected with my ideas than whether other VCs approved of the format.” —Kate McAndrew, cofounder, Baukunst
McAndrew’s hard-earned advice: “My advice to women in VC is to focus on building your track record before building your personal brand. I spent over a decade sourcing deals, supporting founders, and building my reputation before I started creating content. Ultimately, credibility in venture comes from delivering results, not visibility. If you’re early in your career, focus on becoming indispensable to your firm.
“When I started making content, I had to get over my own fear of being judged. I approached it like an entrepreneur: as a calculated risk. I committed to a six-month experiment, posting three times a week, and measured the business outcomes. Today, my content can generate over a million views in a few days, but what matters more are the deals we’ve sourced and the value we’ve created for our portfolio companies.”
“I’ve gotten totally contradictory advice about incorporating my values into my branding over the years. I’ve talked to successful Palestinian business owners, who advised me never to disclose that my company and team are Palestinian. ‘The clients don’t need to know—and as long as the work gets done and you bring business to Palestine, it doesn’t matter!’
“On the opposite side of the scale, I’ve had people tell me I should make my brand all about Palestine. I think the sweet spot is somewhere in the middle. Palestine is an important element in my narrative, but it’s not everything. When it comes to my business, I can’t hide the fact that it’s Palestinian—that would be doing my team a disservice. However, they are not just Palestinian. They have so much more to offer.” —Kathrine Nicolaisen, founder and CEO, Olives & Heather, a fractional marketing team powered by Palestinian marketers and designers
Nicolaisen’s hard-earned advice: “There must be a sweet spot that allows me to build a business with soul and values while still being commercially viable. In the wake of the growing solidarity movement supporting Palestine, we’ve seen a slurry of businesses pop up. Some are well-intentioned and genuinely supporting Palestine; others are profiting off the public goodwill. By choosing to be 100% committed to a solidarity positioning, you not only risk losing out on potential business opportunities, because people don’t see your deeper value and capabilities—you also risk appropriating the cause you’re supporting. This is not limited to Palestine, of course. Think of any brand accused of pinkwashing or greenwashing.”
“I’m not the first, and won’t be the last, to run into ageism and sexism in a male-dominated sphere, but it comes with the territory and I’ve been able to navigate it the way plenty of women before me have had to. Early on, I was told to be cold, distant, more aggressive in order to be taken seriously in the tech sector, but that never actually fit who I am.” —Heather Delaney, founder, Gallium Ventures
Delaney’s hard-earned advice: “The best advice is to stay true to who you are and try not to conform to what you think people want, as conforming moves you into the crowd when standing out might be better.
“Let me give an example: I have been in countless meetings where football was discussed. I observed people trying to show their ‘knowledge’ by jumping into the conversation to gain visibility with senior staff and build relationships. It was obvious they didn’t understand the sport, but they had scraped random facts online just to join in. When asked if I followed the sport, I admitted I didn’t, explained the limits of my knowledge, and instead mentioned two alternative sports I do follow, asking if they knew anything about them. This actually proved a far more energetic chat because it was less generic, and it turned out the other parties did have a genuine interest.”
“A core part of my personal brand is something most people in media don’t do: I don’t share my photo online. When I was invited by President Obama to a White House dinner, I turned down photos there, too, because I knew they’d end up posted publicly. It ties to my observance of hijab, and the choice isn’t just personal. It’s often tangled up with the Islamophobia that can follow visibility for Muslim women. Over time, not sharing my photo has become an intentional part of how I show up professionally. My work speaks first, not my face.” —Tasmiha Khan, independent writer, consultant, strategist
Khan’s hard-earned advice: “Decide your nonnegotiables before the playbook decides for you. Know what you won’t put online, whether that’s your face or your family, and be at peace with what that costs. You may also have to build your own thing, because many professional spaces weren’t designed for a working mother, or a mother who wears a hijab and wants to stay strong in her faith.”
The figurehead: How to cope when your face becomes your business
“The biggest challenge is feeling like your physicality, your face, your body, the person who’s talking on the screen, is inherently tied to [your brand]. I think that’s what we’re going to see a lot over the next decade, because so many creators are building these one-person media companies. Yes, they’ll have teams around them or freelancers, but it really is being defined by the individual.” —Sammi Cohen, founder, Social Currency
Cohen’s hard-earned advice: “If you want to build something that scales beyond you, you really have to create this community and ecosystem that stands for something that’s much larger than yourself.
“With Social Currency, I have a podcast; I started a newsletter. I was really excited about the opportunity to create Social Currency as a platform that’s standing for something that’s not necessarily tied to myself. My one-liner is, “Talking about the hottest business lore.” It’s the place where you go when you want to know the latest and greatest about an interesting company, whether that’s tech or beauty.
“[This fall, I launched a livestream show.] I’m excited about that because, first, I’m going to have a cohost, so I’m going to have someone else—it’s not just me. Second, I think that there is a real opportunity for that network once it gets off the ground and does well, to bring on other shows that are more concentrated in certain verticals.”
“There are plenty of people who are not interested in having any part of this—not interested in social media or LinkedIn or creating this outward-facing persona that everybody can look at and make judgments about. Some people just want to live their lives and not think about any of that. That kind of pressure, I think, can be a little bit silly.
“By extension, taking these principles that make more sense in the context of celebrities or influencers or professional athletes, and then trying to apply them to regular people—let alone regular teenagers—I think is unnecessary. It gets us into this strange place of, ‘What’s your trademark?’ and ‘What are the aspects of your personal brand that you can protect?’ Yeah, maybe that makes sense if you’re Posh Spice and David Beckham, but it doesn’t make that much sense for your average human being.” —Alexandra Roberts, professor of law and media, Northeastern University; author, “Litigating Personal Brand: Intellectual Property & the Construction of Self”
Roberts’s hard-earned advice: “In my research on personal brand and intellectual property, I’ve seen folks increasingly urged to register their names with the trademark office and their video posts with the copyright office or actively cultivate endorsement deals. Most people don’t need to do those things, nor do they need to produce a constant stream of content or craft a persona that’s distinct from their real self. The celebrity personal brand playbook can also create pressure to look perfect, which can be harmful for young people in particular.
“I don’t believe that establishing and maintaining a personal brand is necessary for everyone, so I would encourage people to resist that pressure. To the extent that you feel you need social media accounts—for example, career services offices encourage students to create LinkedIn profiles, and publishers may urge authors to share updates on Instagram—hold your boundaries and only share what feels comfortable to you and relevant to your goals.”
Dealing with The Man: When your workplace becomes a barrier
“Part of me leaving academic medicine was being unburdened from the pressure of not being able to speak up. What I realized is that I never really considered myself a leader because I didn’t see many people who looked like me as a leader. I didn’t see people who I thought were sensitive and compassionate as leaders. When I left in 2019 and then the world went sideways, I actually had an opportunity to step up to be that voice.” —Dr. Uché Blackstock, founder and CEO, Advancing Health Equity
Blackstock’s hard-earned advice: “Find your community within your organization or company. Identify colleagues or coworkers who share your values, build relationships with people you trust, and don’t be afraid to be vulnerable about what you’re experiencing. You may even find that other people are struggling with the same things, and those conversations can open the door to collective action.
“I would also encourage people to be strategic about how they advocate for change. It’s important to look for opportunities to connect your concerns to your company’s stated mission and values, and to identify allies who may be in positions to influence decisions. At the same time, we have to acknowledge that speaking up carries real risks, and those risks aren’t distributed equally. Not everyone has the same professional standing, financial security, or institutional protections.
“This December will mark seven years since I left academic medicine and founded Advancing Health Equity. At the time, I thought I was making a decision to leave an environment that no longer felt healthy for me. But with the benefit of hindsight, I realize I was making a much bigger decision about the kind of personal and professional life I wanted to create for myself.”
“Companies encourage employees to become visible experts when that visibility helps the company. The norms get murky when the employee is building intellectual property, an audience, or a body of work that belongs to her.” —Amy C. Benner Anand, senior agentic solutions sales adviser, Microsoft
Anand’s hard-earned advice: “Find out which rules are actually written down before you start obeying the unwritten ones. Understand your employer’s policies on outside activities, IP, and confidentiality. Those are real, and the risks vary a lot depending on where you work. When appropriate, a simple ‘Views are my own’ can go a long way toward clarifying whose perspective you’re sharing, though it doesn’t override those obligations. Then question the other restrictions you’ve placed on yourself. Where did they come from, and who are they serving?”